Digital payment platforms have become core infrastructure for everyday financial life, but the emotional experience of using them is poorly understood from a design perspective. As transactions grow faster and more abstract, the feedback mechanisms users once relied on to understand their financial activity have eroded. What fills, or fails to fill, that space is a design problem. The research followed a sequential multi-method design: a benchmarking analysis of digital payment platforms in Europe; a digital ethnography of roughly 1,700 posts and comments from Reddit communities dedicated to PayPal, Revolut, and Wise; and ten semi-structured interviews with users in Europe, predominantly international students. Analysis produced six themes: payment uncertainty and waiting anxiety; trust and platform credibility; account restrictions and verification barriers; international transfers and cross-border friction; subscription traps and hidden charges; and the need for transparency, control, and clear communication. The primary source of emotional distress is not financial loss but communicative absence: users left without information at precisely the moments when it is most urgently needed. This holds across platforms, nationalities, and transaction types. Most users encounter friction; a smaller subset, particularly users from sanctioned countries, encounter structural exclusion that communicative design can partially address but not resolve. These findings are developed into the Communicative Presence Model (CPM), organised around four dimensions: Status Legibility, Process Transparency, Consent Visibility, and Recovery Legibility. Nine evidence-based design principles follow, each grounded in specific empirical failure modes. The CPM is offered as a practical tool for designers in digital financial products: precise enough to identify where communicative presence is absent, specific enough to say what restoring it requires.
Le piattaforme digitali di pagamento sono diventate un'infrastruttura centrale della vita finanziaria quotidiana, ma l'esperienza emotiva del loro utilizzo è ancora poco compresa dal punto di vista del design. Con transazioni sempre più veloci e astratte, i meccanismi di feedback su cui gli utenti facevano affidamento per comprendere la propria attività finanziaria si sono progressivamente erosi. Ciò che riempie, o non riesce a riempire, quello spazio è un problema di design. La ricerca ha seguito un disegno multi-metodo sequenziale: un'analisi di benchmarking delle piattaforme di pagamento digitale in Europa; un'etnografia digitale di circa 1.700 post e commenti provenienti da comunità Reddit dedicate a PayPal, Revolut e Wise; e dieci interviste semi-strutturate con utenti in Europa, prevalentemente studenti internazionali. L'analisi ha prodotto sei temi: incertezza nei pagamenti e ansia da attesa; fiducia e credibilità della piattaforma; restrizioni degli account e barriere di verifica; trasferimenti internazionali e attrito transfrontaliero; trappole da abbonamento e costi nascosti; e il bisogno di trasparenza, controllo e comunicazione chiara. La fonte primaria di disagio emotivo non è la perdita finanziaria ma l'assenza comunicativa: utenti lasciati senza informazioni esattamente nei momenti in cui ne hanno più urgentemente bisogno. Questo vale trasversalmente a piattaforme, nazionalità e tipologie di transazione. La maggior parte degli utenti incontra attrito; una minoranza, in particolare gli utenti provenienti da paesi sanzionati, incontra un'esclusione strutturale che il design comunicativo può affrontare solo parzialmente. Questi risultati vengono sviluppati nel Communicative Presence Model (CPM), organizzato attorno a quattro dimensioni: Status Legibility, Process Transparency, Consent Visibility e Recovery Legibility. Ne derivano nove principi di design basati sull'evidenza empirica, ciascuno radicato in specifici fallimenti riscontrati sul campo. Il CPM viene proposto come strumento pratico per i designer che operano nei prodotti finanziari digitali: abbastanza preciso da identificare dove l'presenza comunicativa è assente, abbastanza specifico da indicare cosa richiede il suo ripristino.
Digital payment UX : users' emotional and cognitive experience
MEHRABI KOSHKI, MARJAN
2025/2026
Abstract
Digital payment platforms have become core infrastructure for everyday financial life, but the emotional experience of using them is poorly understood from a design perspective. As transactions grow faster and more abstract, the feedback mechanisms users once relied on to understand their financial activity have eroded. What fills, or fails to fill, that space is a design problem. The research followed a sequential multi-method design: a benchmarking analysis of digital payment platforms in Europe; a digital ethnography of roughly 1,700 posts and comments from Reddit communities dedicated to PayPal, Revolut, and Wise; and ten semi-structured interviews with users in Europe, predominantly international students. Analysis produced six themes: payment uncertainty and waiting anxiety; trust and platform credibility; account restrictions and verification barriers; international transfers and cross-border friction; subscription traps and hidden charges; and the need for transparency, control, and clear communication. The primary source of emotional distress is not financial loss but communicative absence: users left without information at precisely the moments when it is most urgently needed. This holds across platforms, nationalities, and transaction types. Most users encounter friction; a smaller subset, particularly users from sanctioned countries, encounter structural exclusion that communicative design can partially address but not resolve. These findings are developed into the Communicative Presence Model (CPM), organised around four dimensions: Status Legibility, Process Transparency, Consent Visibility, and Recovery Legibility. Nine evidence-based design principles follow, each grounded in specific empirical failure modes. The CPM is offered as a practical tool for designers in digital financial products: precise enough to identify where communicative presence is absent, specific enough to say what restoring it requires.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
2026-07-MehrabiKoshki.pdf
accessibile in internet solo dagli utenti autorizzati
Descrizione: Digital Payment UX
Dimensione
8.82 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
8.82 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
I documenti in POLITesi sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/10589/260120