Codified knowledge often lacks transferability. Although a report, a toolkit, and even an entry in a repository can satisfy all documentary criteria of completeness, it may leave a recipient unable to reconstruct the practice described. Although the issues of stickiness of knowledge have been widely recognized by economics and knowledge management disciplines (and accepted that knowledge is tacit, situational, and path- dependent), the reasons behind the erosion of these features through codification process have rarely been explored. In the authors opinion, it is mainly the ontological issue at stake, and the ontological question could be formulated using Heideggerian definition of knowing, elaborated by Dreyfus and further discussed with Polanyi, Nonaka, and Tsoukas. Thus, my research question is: under which circumstances codification makes an artifact reconstructable for a person who was not involved in situational practice that produced it. Using the above understanding of knowing, a set of four ontological criteria is derived: situational anchoring, practical orientation, temporal transparency, and relational traceability; and used to analyze any codified output. The framework is exemplified through the analysis of the UNDP Accelerator Labs project, coding approximately twenty codified knowledge artifacts in different levels of documentation network.
La conoscenza codificata spesso difetta di trasferibilità. Sebbene un report, un toolkit o persino una voce in un repository possano soddisfare tutti i criteri documentali di completezza, ciò può comunque lasciare il destinatario incapace di ricostruire la pratica descritta. Per quanto i problemi di vischiosità (stickiness) della conoscenza siano stati ampiamente riconosciuti dalle discipline economiche e dal knowledge management — che accettano la natura tacita, situata e path-dependent della conoscenza — le ragioni alla base dell'erosione di tali caratteristiche attraverso il processo di codificazione sono state raramente indagate. A parere di chi scrive, la questione in gioco è essenzialmente di natura ontologica, e l'interrogativo ontologico può essere formulato a partire dalla definizione heideggeriana del conoscere, elaborata da Dreyfus e ulteriormente discussa attraverso Polanyi, Nonaka e Tsoukas. La domanda di ricerca è dunque la seguente: a quali condizioni la codificazione rende un artefatto ricostruibile per una persona che non ha preso parte alla pratica situata che lo ha prodotto. Sulla base di questa concezione del conoscere viene derivato un insieme di quattro criteri ontologici — ancoraggio situazionale, orientamento pratico, trasparenza temporale e tracciabilità relazionale — impiegati per analizzare qualsiasi output codificato. Il framework è esemplificato attraverso l'analisi del progetto UNDP Accelerator Labs, codificando circa venti artefatti di conoscenza codificata nei diversi livelli della rete documentale.
Being, knowing and the network: a heiddegerian ontology of knowledge codification is sustainable knowledge ecosystems
Olivetti, Edoardo Maria
2025/2026
Abstract
Codified knowledge often lacks transferability. Although a report, a toolkit, and even an entry in a repository can satisfy all documentary criteria of completeness, it may leave a recipient unable to reconstruct the practice described. Although the issues of stickiness of knowledge have been widely recognized by economics and knowledge management disciplines (and accepted that knowledge is tacit, situational, and path- dependent), the reasons behind the erosion of these features through codification process have rarely been explored. In the authors opinion, it is mainly the ontological issue at stake, and the ontological question could be formulated using Heideggerian definition of knowing, elaborated by Dreyfus and further discussed with Polanyi, Nonaka, and Tsoukas. Thus, my research question is: under which circumstances codification makes an artifact reconstructable for a person who was not involved in situational practice that produced it. Using the above understanding of knowing, a set of four ontological criteria is derived: situational anchoring, practical orientation, temporal transparency, and relational traceability; and used to analyze any codified output. The framework is exemplified through the analysis of the UNDP Accelerator Labs project, coding approximately twenty codified knowledge artifacts in different levels of documentation network.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
2026_07_Olivetti.pdf
non accessibile
Descrizione: Tesi magistrale Edoardo Maria Olivetti
Dimensione
1.59 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
1.59 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
I documenti in POLITesi sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/10589/260135