The rapid growth of variable renewable energy sources (VRES) is increasing short-term volatility and forecast uncertainty in power systems, making flexibility an essential requirement for reliable operation. Among the available solutions, Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) have emerged as effective assets, owing to their fast response, high efficiency, and ability to provide multiple services such as energy shifting, frequency regulation, and balancing. In Italy, the economic viability of grid-connected storage is strongly shaped by an evolving market design and ongoing regulatory reforms, including TIDE and the introduction of long-term procurement mechanisms such as MACSE. This thesis develops a techno-economic framework to compare alternative route-to-market strategies for BESS, covering merchant, contracted, and hybrid configurations. The framework integrates technical characteristics, market assumptions, and a detailed financial model within a unified Excel-based structure, enabling a consistent comparison across business models. Applied to a 100 MW / 800 MWh reference asset, the analysis evaluates revenues, utilization, and key financial indicators such as Net Present Value (NPV) and Internal Rate of Return (IRR). A purely contracted configuration barely clears its cost of capital (NPV near zero, IRR about 4.3%), whereas a pure merchant strategy reaches the highest first-year revenue (13.69 M€) but a lower risk-adjusted return (NPV 5.45 M€, IRR 9.80%) due to its steeper decline and higher required return. Hybrid configurations perform best, with the MACSE + merchant reference yielding an NPV of 9.21 M€ (IRR 11.30%) and a merchant + Capacity Market combination reaching 32.61 M€ (IRR 22.61%). These results quantify the trade-off between maximizing returns and ensuring revenue stability, showing that pairing a contracted floor with controlled market exposure improves robustness while preserving operational flexibility.
La rapida crescita delle fonti di energia rinnovabile variabile (VRES) sta aumentando la volatilità a breve termine e l'incertezza previsionale nei sistemi elettrici, rendendo la flessibilità un requisito essenziale per un'operazione affidabile. Tra le soluzioni disponibili, i sistemi di accumulo a batteria (BESS) si sono affermati come risorse efficaci, grazie alla loro rapida risposta, all'elevata efficienza e alla capacità di fornire molteplici servizi quali lo spostamento di energia, la regolazione della frequenza e il bilanciamento. In Italia, la redditività economica dello stoccaggio connesso alla rete è fortemente influenzata da un quadro di mercato in evoluzione e da riforme regolamentari in corso, tra cui TIDE e l'introduzione di meccanismi di approvvigionamento a lungo termine come il MACSE. Questa tesi sviluppa un framework tecno-economico per confrontare strategie alternative di route-to-market per i BESS, comprendendo configurazioni merchant, contrattualizzate e ibride. Il framework integra caratteristiche tecniche, ipotesi di mercato e un modello finanziario dettagliato all'interno di una struttura unificata basata su Excel, consentendo un confronto coerente tra i diversi modelli di business. Applicata a un asset di riferimento da 100 MW / 800 MWh, l'analisi valuta i ricavi, l'utilizzo e i principali indicatori finanziari quali il Net Present Value (NPV) e l'Internal Rate of Return (IRR). Una configurazione puramente contrattualizzata supera a malapena il costo del capitale (NPV prossimo a zero, IRR di circa 4,3%), mentre una strategia puramente merchant raggiunge il maggiore ricavo nel primo anno (13,69 M€) ma un rendimento corretto per il rischio inferiore (NPV 5,45 M€, IRR 9,80%) a causa del suo declino più accentuato e del maggiore rendimento richiesto. Le configurazioni ibride ottengono i risultati migliori: la configurazione di riferimento MACSE + merchant genera un NPV di 9,21 M€ (IRR 11,30%) e la combinazione merchant + Capacity Market raggiunge 32,61 M€ (IRR 22,61%). Questi risultati quantificano il trade-off tra massimizzazione dei rendimenti e garanzia di stabilità dei ricavi, mostrando che l'abbinamento di un ricavo minimo contrattualizzato con un'esposizione controllata al mercato migliora la robustezza preservando al contempo la flessibilità operativa.
A techno-economic comparision of business models for battery energy storage system in Italy
HU, JUNFU ADRIANO
2025/2026
Abstract
The rapid growth of variable renewable energy sources (VRES) is increasing short-term volatility and forecast uncertainty in power systems, making flexibility an essential requirement for reliable operation. Among the available solutions, Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) have emerged as effective assets, owing to their fast response, high efficiency, and ability to provide multiple services such as energy shifting, frequency regulation, and balancing. In Italy, the economic viability of grid-connected storage is strongly shaped by an evolving market design and ongoing regulatory reforms, including TIDE and the introduction of long-term procurement mechanisms such as MACSE. This thesis develops a techno-economic framework to compare alternative route-to-market strategies for BESS, covering merchant, contracted, and hybrid configurations. The framework integrates technical characteristics, market assumptions, and a detailed financial model within a unified Excel-based structure, enabling a consistent comparison across business models. Applied to a 100 MW / 800 MWh reference asset, the analysis evaluates revenues, utilization, and key financial indicators such as Net Present Value (NPV) and Internal Rate of Return (IRR). A purely contracted configuration barely clears its cost of capital (NPV near zero, IRR about 4.3%), whereas a pure merchant strategy reaches the highest first-year revenue (13.69 M€) but a lower risk-adjusted return (NPV 5.45 M€, IRR 9.80%) due to its steeper decline and higher required return. Hybrid configurations perform best, with the MACSE + merchant reference yielding an NPV of 9.21 M€ (IRR 11.30%) and a merchant + Capacity Market combination reaching 32.61 M€ (IRR 22.61%). These results quantify the trade-off between maximizing returns and ensuring revenue stability, showing that pairing a contracted floor with controlled market exposure improves robustness while preserving operational flexibility.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
2026_07_Hu.pdf
accessibile in internet solo dagli utenti autorizzati
Dimensione
2.2 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
2.2 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
I documenti in POLITesi sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/10589/260213