This thesis explores the role of economic-financial evaluation in support of architectural design choices, with specific reference to a residential development project, which intervenes on the roof of a commercial building located in a central area of the city of Milan. The work is part of the broader contemporary debate regarding the containment of land consumption and the search for innovative strategies of sustainable urban development, with particular attention to the dynamics of densification and reuse of already urbanized surfaces. In an urban context with high real estate pressure such as that of Milan, characterized by a growing housing demand and by a limited availability of buildable areas, the use of the roofs of large commercial structures emerges as a possible strategic solution. The hypothesis is not limited to responding to the housing issue; the growth of e-commerce has in fact reduced the necessity of large retail structures inserted in the urban fabric, which today could require a downsizing of surfaces or a functional reconversion of some portions. The first part of the thesis is dedicated to the analysis of the regulatory framework that governs land consumption, with a multi-level in-depth study that includes the national, regional (Lombardy), and municipal scale, with particular reference to the urban planning instruments in force in the Municipality of Milan. This investigation makes it possible to reconstruct the legislative path that has led to the progressive limitation of land consumption, highlighting the main regulations that have governed its use and the policies that have promoted its reduction. In this context, the possibility of intervening on the roofs of existing buildings is also analyzed, verifying whether and to what extent commercial structures, such as supermarkets, may benefit from additional building rights or from vertical extension operations compatible with urban planning constraints. Starting from this framework, the second chapter explores the potential of roofs as spatial “devices” to address some of the most urgent challenges with which urban planning is called to confront itself. This approach, first of all, confronts the current criticalities of the Milanese real estate market, marked by a significant shortage of affordable housing. The project hypothesis therefore configures itself not only as a theoretical exercise, but as a concrete response to real needs, proposing a mode of intervention that makes it possible to increase housing density while avoiding further land consumption. Furthermore, this type of intervention would also represent an opportunity for a possible downsizing of large retail structures, which today, in some urban contexts, are “threatened” by the spread of e-commerce. The third chapter is dedicated to the analysis of European case studies, characterized by analogous design approaches, namely in which residential interventions above commercial buildings or large retail surfaces have been realized. Such experiences are examined mainly from the economic-financial and managerial point of view, with particular attention to the public-private partnership models adopted, the modalities of granting spaces, the applied fees, and the strategies for the distribution of benefits among the subjects involved. In parallel, some relevant architectural aspects are recalled, useful for understanding the adopted design choices and for demonstrating the technical feasibility and the quality of the realized interventions, thus strengthening the validity of the hypothesis developed in the thesis. Chapter 4 introduces the main case study, which concerns the roof of the Esselunga supermarket on Via Losanna in Milan, for which a design proposal accompanied by an economic-financial analysis model is developed. In this context, the role of a real estate operator (developer) called to interact with two main interlocutors is outlined: on one side the owner subject of the commercial property, with whom to negotiate the acquisition of the usage rights of the roof and the definition of the related fees; on the other side the municipal administration, with which to agree on the buildable volume in compliance with the limits imposed by the Territorial Government Plan (PGT), as well as the quotas of social residential housing to integrate into the project. Through the construction of different design and financial scenarios, the thesis evaluates the economic sustainability of the intervention, analyzing variables such as the realizable volume, the functional mix, the incidence of subsidized housing, construction costs, and expected economic flows. The analysis makes it possible to highlight the relationships among the different components of the project and their impact on the overall profitability of the operation. The central contribution of the thesis lies in the identification of an optimal scenario capable of mediating among the needs of the three main actors involved: the developer, interested in the maximization of profit; the private subject owner of the commercial property, oriented toward the valorization of its asset through the granting of the roof; and the public administration, committed to guaranteeing the collective interest through urban regulation and the promotion of social housing. The final objective is therefore the identification of a point of equilibrium among these three subjects, defining a design and economic configuration that represents the best possible compromise, capable of maximizing the overall benefit and making the intervention concretely feasible.
La presente tesi esplora il ruolo della valutazione economico-finanziaria a supporto delle scelte di progettazione architettonica, con specifico riferimento a un progetto di sviluppo residenziale, che interviene sulla copertura di un edificio commerciale situato in un’area centrale della città di Milano. L’elaborato si inserisce nel più ampio dibattito contemporaneo relativo al contenimento del consumo di suolo e alla ricerca di strategie innovative di sviluppo urbano sostenibile, con particolare attenzione alle dinamiche di densificazione e riuso delle superfici già urbanizzate. In un contesto urbano ad alta pressione immobiliare come quello milanese, caratterizzato da una crescente domanda abitativa e da una limitata disponibilità di aree edificabili, l’utilizzo delle coperture di grandi strutture commerciali emerge come una possibile soluzione strategica. L’ipotesi non si limita a rispondere alla questione abitativa; la crescita dell’e-commerce ha infatti ridotto la necessità delle grandi strutture di vendita inserite nel tessuto urbano, che oggi potrebbero richiedere un ridimensionamento delle superfici o una riconversione funzionale di alcune porzioni. La prima parte della tesi è dedicata all’analisi del quadro normativo che disciplina il consumo di suolo, con un approfondimento multilivello che comprende la scala nazionale, regionale (Lombardia) e comunale, con particolare riferimento agli strumenti urbanistici vigenti nel Comune di Milano. Tale indagine consente di ricostruire il percorso legislativo che ha portato alla progressiva limitazione del consumo di suolo, evidenziando le principali normative che ne hanno regolamentato l’utilizzo e le politiche che ne hanno promosso la riduzione. In questo contesto, viene inoltre analizzata la possibilità di intervenire sulle coperture di edifici esistenti, verificando se e in quale misura strutture commerciali, come i supermercati, possano beneficiare di diritti edificatori aggiuntivi o di operazioni di sopraelevazione compatibili con i vincoli urbanistici. A partire da tale inquadramento, il secondo capitolo esplora il potenziale delle coperture come “dispositivi” spaziali per affrontare alcune delle sfide più urgenti con cui è chiamata a confrontarsi la pianificazione urbana. Questo approccio, in primis, si confronta con le criticità attuali del mercato immobiliare milanese, segnato da una significativa carenza di alloggi accessibili. L’ipotesi progettuale si configura quindi non solo come un esercizio teorico, ma come una risposta concreta a esigenze reali, proponendo una modalità di intervento che consente di aumentare la densità abitativa evitando ulteriore consumo di suolo. Inoltre, questo tipo di intervento rappresenterebbe un’opportunità anche per un possibile downsizing delle grandi strutture di vendita, che ad oggi, in alcuni contesti urbani, sono “minacciate” dal diffondersi dell’e-commerce Il terzo capitolo è dedicato all’analisi di casi studio europei, caratterizzati da approcci progettuali analoghi, ovvero nei quali sono stati realizzati interventi residenziali sopra edifici commerciali o grandi superfici di vendita. Tali esperienze vengono esaminate principalmente dal punto di vista economico-finanziario e gestionale, con particolare attenzione ai modelli di partnership pubblico-privato adottati, alle modalità di concessione degli spazi, ai canoni applicati e alle strategie di ripartizione dei benefici tra i soggetti coinvolti. Parallelamente, vengono richiamati alcuni aspetti architettonici rilevanti, utili a comprendere le scelte progettuali adottate e a dimostrare la fattibilità tecnica e la qualità degli interventi realizzati, rafforzando così la validità dell’ipotesi sviluppata nella tesi. Il quarto capitolo introduce il caso studio principale, che riguarda la copertura del supermercato Esselunga di via Losanna a Milano, per il quale viene sviluppata una proposta progettuale accompagnata da un modello di analisi economico-finanziaria. In questo contesto, viene delineato il ruolo di un operatore immobiliare (developer) chiamato a interagire con due principali interlocutori: da un lato il soggetto proprietario dell’immobile commerciale, con cui negoziare l’acquisizione dei diritti d’uso della copertura e la definizione dei relativi canoni; dall’altro l’amministrazione comunale, con cui concordare la volumetria edificabile nel rispetto dei limiti imposti dal Piano di Governo del Territorio (PGT), nonché le quote di edilizia residenziale sociale da integrare nel progetto. Attraverso la costruzione di diversi scenari progettuali e finanziari, la tesi valuta la sostenibilità economica dell’intervento, analizzando variabili quali la volumetria realizzabile, il mix funzionale, l’incidenza dell’edilizia convenzionata, i costi di costruzione e i flussi economici attesi. L’analisi consente di mettere in luce le relazioni tra le diverse componenti del progetto e il loro impatto sulla redditività complessiva dell’operazione. Il contributo centrale della tesi risiede nell’individuazione di uno scenario ottimale in grado di mediare tra le esigenze dei tre attori principali coinvolti: il developer, interessato alla massimizzazione del profitto; il soggetto privato proprietario dell’immobile commerciale, orientato alla valorizzazione del proprio asset attraverso la concessione della copertura; e l’amministrazione pubblica, impegnata a garantire l’interesse collettivo attraverso la regolazione urbanistica e la promozione dell’edilizia sociale. L’obiettivo finale è quindi l’identificazione di un punto di equilibrio tra questi tre soggetti, definendo una configurazione progettuale ed economica che rappresenti il miglior compromesso possibile, in grado di massimizzare il beneficio complessivo e rendere l’intervento concretamente realizzabile.
The super deal : dalla copertura commerciale all'housing accessibile: costruire valore tra pubblico e privato
LABO, ADRIANO
2025/2026
Abstract
This thesis explores the role of economic-financial evaluation in support of architectural design choices, with specific reference to a residential development project, which intervenes on the roof of a commercial building located in a central area of the city of Milan. The work is part of the broader contemporary debate regarding the containment of land consumption and the search for innovative strategies of sustainable urban development, with particular attention to the dynamics of densification and reuse of already urbanized surfaces. In an urban context with high real estate pressure such as that of Milan, characterized by a growing housing demand and by a limited availability of buildable areas, the use of the roofs of large commercial structures emerges as a possible strategic solution. The hypothesis is not limited to responding to the housing issue; the growth of e-commerce has in fact reduced the necessity of large retail structures inserted in the urban fabric, which today could require a downsizing of surfaces or a functional reconversion of some portions. The first part of the thesis is dedicated to the analysis of the regulatory framework that governs land consumption, with a multi-level in-depth study that includes the national, regional (Lombardy), and municipal scale, with particular reference to the urban planning instruments in force in the Municipality of Milan. This investigation makes it possible to reconstruct the legislative path that has led to the progressive limitation of land consumption, highlighting the main regulations that have governed its use and the policies that have promoted its reduction. In this context, the possibility of intervening on the roofs of existing buildings is also analyzed, verifying whether and to what extent commercial structures, such as supermarkets, may benefit from additional building rights or from vertical extension operations compatible with urban planning constraints. Starting from this framework, the second chapter explores the potential of roofs as spatial “devices” to address some of the most urgent challenges with which urban planning is called to confront itself. This approach, first of all, confronts the current criticalities of the Milanese real estate market, marked by a significant shortage of affordable housing. The project hypothesis therefore configures itself not only as a theoretical exercise, but as a concrete response to real needs, proposing a mode of intervention that makes it possible to increase housing density while avoiding further land consumption. Furthermore, this type of intervention would also represent an opportunity for a possible downsizing of large retail structures, which today, in some urban contexts, are “threatened” by the spread of e-commerce. The third chapter is dedicated to the analysis of European case studies, characterized by analogous design approaches, namely in which residential interventions above commercial buildings or large retail surfaces have been realized. Such experiences are examined mainly from the economic-financial and managerial point of view, with particular attention to the public-private partnership models adopted, the modalities of granting spaces, the applied fees, and the strategies for the distribution of benefits among the subjects involved. In parallel, some relevant architectural aspects are recalled, useful for understanding the adopted design choices and for demonstrating the technical feasibility and the quality of the realized interventions, thus strengthening the validity of the hypothesis developed in the thesis. Chapter 4 introduces the main case study, which concerns the roof of the Esselunga supermarket on Via Losanna in Milan, for which a design proposal accompanied by an economic-financial analysis model is developed. In this context, the role of a real estate operator (developer) called to interact with two main interlocutors is outlined: on one side the owner subject of the commercial property, with whom to negotiate the acquisition of the usage rights of the roof and the definition of the related fees; on the other side the municipal administration, with which to agree on the buildable volume in compliance with the limits imposed by the Territorial Government Plan (PGT), as well as the quotas of social residential housing to integrate into the project. Through the construction of different design and financial scenarios, the thesis evaluates the economic sustainability of the intervention, analyzing variables such as the realizable volume, the functional mix, the incidence of subsidized housing, construction costs, and expected economic flows. The analysis makes it possible to highlight the relationships among the different components of the project and their impact on the overall profitability of the operation. The central contribution of the thesis lies in the identification of an optimal scenario capable of mediating among the needs of the three main actors involved: the developer, interested in the maximization of profit; the private subject owner of the commercial property, oriented toward the valorization of its asset through the granting of the roof; and the public administration, committed to guaranteeing the collective interest through urban regulation and the promotion of social housing. The final objective is therefore the identification of a point of equilibrium among these three subjects, defining a design and economic configuration that represents the best possible compromise, capable of maximizing the overall benefit and making the intervention concretely feasible.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Adriano_Labo_Super Deal_Dalla copertura commerciale all’housing accessibile_costruire valore tra pubblico e privato_.pdf
accessibile in internet solo dagli utenti autorizzati
Dimensione
122.56 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
122.56 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
I documenti in POLITesi sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/10589/260482