This thesis presents a three-dimensional finite element investigation of the composite pressure hull of the Titan submersible, with particular focus on the influence of manufacturinginduced defects and the potential contribution of hygrothermal ageing to the structural degradation of the hull. A detailed Abaqus model was developed using solid composite elements to reproduce the multi-block architecture of the structure, including adhesive interfaces and titanium components. The laminate stacking sequence was reconstructed from the available investigation reports and implemented through an explicit through-thickness discretisation. Two configurations were analysed: a nominal model representing the intact structure and a degraded model incorporating a representative defect derived from the manufacturing irregularities documented during the Marine Board of Investigation. The structural response was evaluated through global stress analyses and local throughthickness stress paths. Particular attention was devoted to stress redistribution within the laminate and across the adhesive interfaces. In addition, the Tsai–Hill failure criterion was implemented to evaluate the influence of the introduced defects on the composite failure tendency by comparing the predicted failure indices with degraded allowable values representative of aged composite materials. The objective of the study is not to identify the direct cause of the TITAN implosion, but to quantify the structural consequences of the reported manufacturing defects. By comparing the Tsai–Hill failure indices obtained from the numerical simulations with degraded admissible values available in the literature, it is possible to assess whether the observed manufacturing defects alone are sufficient to explain the reduction in structural integrity or whether additional degradation mechanisms, such as hygrothermal ageing associated with prolonged exposure to the marine environment and repeated dive cycles, may have contributed significantly to the loss of load-carrying capacity.
La presente tesi sviluppa un’analisi tridimensionale agli elementi finiti dello scafo in materiale composito del sommergibile Titan, con particolare attenzione all’influenza dei difetti di fabbricazione e al potenziale contributo dell’invecchiamento igrotermico sul degrado strutturale dello scafo. È stato sviluppato un modello dettagliato in Abaqus utilizzando elementi solidi per materiali compositi al fine di riprodurre l’architettura multiblocco della struttura, comprese le interfacce adesive e i componenti in titanio. La sequenza di laminazione è stata ricostruita sulla base dei rapporti d’indagine disponibili. Sono state analizzate due configurazioni: un modello nominale rappresentativo della struttura integra e un modello degradato comprendente un difetto rappresentativo derivato dalle irregolarità di fabbricazione documentate nel Marine Board of Investigation. La risposta strutturale è stata valutata mediante analisi degli stati tensionali globali e percorsi tensionali locali attraverso lo spessore. Particolare attenzione è stata dedicata alla ridistribuzione delle tensioni all’interno del laminato e attraverso le interfacce adesive. Inoltre, è stato implementato il criterio di cedimento di Tsai-Hill per valutare l’influenza dei difetti introdotti sulla tendenza al cedimento del composito confrontando gli indici di cedimento previsti con valori ammissibili degradati rappresentativi di materiali compositi invecchiati. L’obiettivo dello studio non è individuare la causa diretta dell’implosione del Titan, bensì quantificare le conseguenze strutturali dei difetti di fabbricazione riportati nelle indagini. Confrontando gli indici di cedimento di Tsai-Hill ottenuti dalle simulazioni numeriche con i corrispondenti valori ammissibili degradati disponibili in letteratura, è possibile valutare se i difetti di fabbricazione osservati siano da soli sufficienti a spiegare la riduzione dell’integrità strutturale oppure se ulteriori meccanismi di degrado, quali l’invecchiamento igrotermico, possano aver contribuito in maniera significativa alla perdita della capacità portante della struttura.
Deep Collapse : technical-forensic analysis of hygrothermal ageing in the Titan disaster
Granata, Giuseppe
2025/2026
Abstract
This thesis presents a three-dimensional finite element investigation of the composite pressure hull of the Titan submersible, with particular focus on the influence of manufacturinginduced defects and the potential contribution of hygrothermal ageing to the structural degradation of the hull. A detailed Abaqus model was developed using solid composite elements to reproduce the multi-block architecture of the structure, including adhesive interfaces and titanium components. The laminate stacking sequence was reconstructed from the available investigation reports and implemented through an explicit through-thickness discretisation. Two configurations were analysed: a nominal model representing the intact structure and a degraded model incorporating a representative defect derived from the manufacturing irregularities documented during the Marine Board of Investigation. The structural response was evaluated through global stress analyses and local throughthickness stress paths. Particular attention was devoted to stress redistribution within the laminate and across the adhesive interfaces. In addition, the Tsai–Hill failure criterion was implemented to evaluate the influence of the introduced defects on the composite failure tendency by comparing the predicted failure indices with degraded allowable values representative of aged composite materials. The objective of the study is not to identify the direct cause of the TITAN implosion, but to quantify the structural consequences of the reported manufacturing defects. By comparing the Tsai–Hill failure indices obtained from the numerical simulations with degraded admissible values available in the literature, it is possible to assess whether the observed manufacturing defects alone are sufficient to explain the reduction in structural integrity or whether additional degradation mechanisms, such as hygrothermal ageing associated with prolonged exposure to the marine environment and repeated dive cycles, may have contributed significantly to the loss of load-carrying capacity.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
2026_07_Granata.pdf
accessibile in internet per tutti
Dimensione
13.77 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
13.77 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
I documenti in POLITesi sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/10589/260507