Increasing complexities in modern supply chain management driven by upstream and downstream networks, as well as operational and external factors, have urged project-based firms to seek new governance mechanisms. Consequently, an increasing number of firms rely on third-party digital intermediaries to support supplier relationship management and mitigate network risks. Traditional literature often assumes a universal best practice for project success, and it relies on the linear accumulation of internal resources and bilateral trust. However, in complex and multi-stakeholder project networks driven by these digital intermediaries, such traditional symmetric assumptions frequently fail to capture the reality. This thesis challenges the linear and symmetric logic to explore how firms achieve high performance through digital intermediation. Drawing on Resource-Based Theory (RBT) and Social Capital Theory (SCT), this research applies fuzzy-set Qualitative Comparative Analysis (fsQCA) and Necessary Condition Analysis (NCA) to 48 empirical cases across five different digital platforms, covering oil & gas, heavy manufacturing, construction, automotive, and technology sectors. The results reveal strong causal asymmetry and equifinality. Specifically, no single internal capability or external resource acts as an absolute prerequisite for success, and multiple distinct combinations of conditions can lead to high performance. These findings show that a universal best practice does not exist in complex environments. Instead, desired outcomes are achieved through diverse configurational pathways. Furthermore, resource deployment does not follow a "more is better" rule. By mapping the conditions into the structural, relational, and cognitive dimensions of SCT, this study discovers a precise cross-dimensional substitution effect. When a firm lacks internal cognitive capacities, the powerful external structural and relational resources provided by the digital intermediary can compensate for these deficits. Ultimately, this thesis conceptualizes a network governance paradigm known as ecosystem governance. This concept not only breaks the traditional bilateral buyer-supplier relationship to a triadic perspective, but proves that disadvantaged firms can achieve high performance by strategically integrating with the intermediary's ecosystem. This study extends the existing theories on resource deployment and compensation, provides a framework for digital intermediary governance and offers actionable pathways for firms in modern digital supply chains.
La crescente complessità della gestione moderna della supply chain, determinata dalle reti a monte e a valle, nonché da fattori operativi ed esterni, ha spinto le imprese basate su progetti a ricercare nuovi meccanismi di governance. Di conseguenza, un numero sempre maggiore di imprese si affida a intermediari digitali di terze parti per supportare la gestione delle relazioni con i fornitori e ridurre i rischi di rete. La letteratura tradizionale assume spesso l'esistenza di una migliore pratica universale per il successo dei progetti e si basa sull'accumulazione lineare di risorse interne e sulla fiducia bilaterale. Tuttavia, nelle reti di progetto complesse e caratterizzate dalla presenza di molteplici attori, supportate da questi intermediari digitali, tali presupposti simmetrici spesso non riescono a rappresentare adeguatamente la realtà. Questa tesi mette in discussione la logica lineare e simmetrica tradizionale per comprendere come le imprese possano raggiungere elevate prestazioni attraverso l'intermediazione digitale. Basandosi sulla Resource-Based Theory (RBT) e sulla Social Capital Theory (SCT), la ricerca applica la fuzzy-set Qualitative Comparative Analysis (fsQCA) e la Necessary Condition Analysis (NCA) a 48 casi empirici provenienti da cinque diverse piattaforme digitali, operanti nei settori dell’oil & gas, della manifattura pesante, delle costruzioni, dell’automotive e della tecnologia. I risultati evidenziano una forte asimmetria causale e il principio di equifinalità. In particolare, nessuna singola capacità interna o risorsa esterna costituisce una condizione necessaria e assoluta per il successo, mentre diverse combinazioni di condizioni possono condurre a elevate prestazioni. Questi risultati dimostrano che negli ambienti complessi non esiste una migliore pratica universale. Al contrario, i risultati desiderati possono essere raggiunti attraverso differenti configurazioni di condizioni. Inoltre, l'impiego delle risorse non segue la logica secondo cui “più risorse significano automaticamente risultati migliori”. Mappando le condizioni nelle dimensioni strutturale, relazionale e cognitiva della Social Capital Theory, lo studio identifica un preciso effetto di sostituzione tra dimensioni differenti. Quando un'impresa dispone di limitate capacità cognitive interne, le risorse strutturali e relazionali fornite dall'intermediario digitale possono compensare tali carenze. Infine, la tesi propone un paradigma di governance delle reti denominato governance degli ecosistemi. Questo concetto non solo supera la tradizionale relazione bilaterale tra acquirente e fornitore introducendo una prospettiva triadica, ma dimostra anche che le imprese in posizione svantaggiata possono raggiungere elevate prestazioni integrandosi strategicamente nell'ecosistema dell'intermediario. Lo studio amplia le teorie esistenti sull'impiego e sulla compensazione delle risorse, fornisce un quadro per la governance degli intermediari digitali e offre indicazioni pratiche e il successo delle imprese nelle moderne supply chain digitali.
A fsQCA study of configurational success through digital intermediaries in project-based supply chains
ZOU, YANG
2025/2026
Abstract
Increasing complexities in modern supply chain management driven by upstream and downstream networks, as well as operational and external factors, have urged project-based firms to seek new governance mechanisms. Consequently, an increasing number of firms rely on third-party digital intermediaries to support supplier relationship management and mitigate network risks. Traditional literature often assumes a universal best practice for project success, and it relies on the linear accumulation of internal resources and bilateral trust. However, in complex and multi-stakeholder project networks driven by these digital intermediaries, such traditional symmetric assumptions frequently fail to capture the reality. This thesis challenges the linear and symmetric logic to explore how firms achieve high performance through digital intermediation. Drawing on Resource-Based Theory (RBT) and Social Capital Theory (SCT), this research applies fuzzy-set Qualitative Comparative Analysis (fsQCA) and Necessary Condition Analysis (NCA) to 48 empirical cases across five different digital platforms, covering oil & gas, heavy manufacturing, construction, automotive, and technology sectors. The results reveal strong causal asymmetry and equifinality. Specifically, no single internal capability or external resource acts as an absolute prerequisite for success, and multiple distinct combinations of conditions can lead to high performance. These findings show that a universal best practice does not exist in complex environments. Instead, desired outcomes are achieved through diverse configurational pathways. Furthermore, resource deployment does not follow a "more is better" rule. By mapping the conditions into the structural, relational, and cognitive dimensions of SCT, this study discovers a precise cross-dimensional substitution effect. When a firm lacks internal cognitive capacities, the powerful external structural and relational resources provided by the digital intermediary can compensate for these deficits. Ultimately, this thesis conceptualizes a network governance paradigm known as ecosystem governance. This concept not only breaks the traditional bilateral buyer-supplier relationship to a triadic perspective, but proves that disadvantaged firms can achieve high performance by strategically integrating with the intermediary's ecosystem. This study extends the existing theories on resource deployment and compensation, provides a framework for digital intermediary governance and offers actionable pathways for firms in modern digital supply chains.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Thesis_Yang_Zou.pdf
non accessibile
Descrizione: A fsQCA Study of Configurational Success through Digital Intermediaries in Project-based Supply Chains
Dimensione
1.88 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
1.88 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
I documenti in POLITesi sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/10589/260667