Over the past decade, professional sports franchises have emerged as a distinct institutional asset class, attracting over USD 54,6 billion in private equity (PE) capital globally by 2024. Despite the scale of this activity, the sports PE market is still missing a transferable, analytically rigorous evaluation framework suited to the multi-criteria nature of sports investment decisions. This thesis addresses that gap through the development and empirical application of a structured multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) framework that evaluates sports PE investments on a 0-100 composite scale, called Sports Private Equity Investment Scoring (SPEIS) model. The model is applied prospectively to three case studies spanning distinct sports markets and regulatory environments: Manchester United-INEOS Sport (English Premier League, 2023), Miami Dolphins-Ares Management (National Football League, 2024), and McLaren Racing-MSP Sports Capital (Formula One, 2020). The model produces differentiated and internally consistent verdicts. Manchester United’s evidence reflects strong brand equity and value-creation lever width offset by execution risk and a full-price entry. The Miami Dolphins presents an expensive EV/EBITDA entry and constrained operational levers under NFL passive-minority ownership rules. McLaren registers financial distress at entry, but with the most compelling override rationale in the sample. This prospective verdict is retrospectively validated by MSP’s confirmed exit in September 2025, placing the investment in the top decile of global PE returns.
Nell'ultimo decennio le aziende sportive professionistiche sono emerse particolarmente come classe di asset istituzionali, attirando, al 2024, oltre 54,6 miliardi di dollari di capitale di private equity (PE). Nonostante ciò, il mercato del PE nello sport è privo di un framework di valutazione strutturato, adatto alla natura complessa delle decisioni di investimento sportivo. Questa tesi sviluppa e applica empiricamente lo Sports Private Equity Investment Scoring (SPEIS), un framework di analisi decisionale multicriterio (ADMC) che valuta gli investimenti PE in ambito sportivo su una scala composita da 0 a 100. Il modello viene applicato in modo prospettico a tre case study che coprono mercati sportivi distinti e diversi contesti regolatori: Manchester United-INEOS Sport (Premier League, 2023), Miami Dolphins-Ares Management (National Football League, 2024) e McLaren Racing-MSP Sports Capital (Formula Uno, 2020). Il modello produce risultati diversi ma coerenti. Il caso Manchester United riflette un forte brand equity e un’ampia gamma di driver di valore, controbilanciate da un rischio di esecuzione e da un prezzo di ingresso elevato. I Miami Dolphins presentano un ingresso a multiplo EV/EBITDA elevato e leve operative vincolate dalle regole di proprietà di minoranza passiva della NFL. McLaren registra una situazione di distress finanziario al momento dell'ingresso, ma con un override particolarmente valido. Questo verdetto prospettico è confermato dall'exit di MSP nel settembre 2025, che colloca l'investimento nel decile superiore dei rendimenti PE globali.
Private equity in the sports industry : a multicriteria investment scoring model
FOTI, GIOVANNI ANTONIO
2025/2026
Abstract
Over the past decade, professional sports franchises have emerged as a distinct institutional asset class, attracting over USD 54,6 billion in private equity (PE) capital globally by 2024. Despite the scale of this activity, the sports PE market is still missing a transferable, analytically rigorous evaluation framework suited to the multi-criteria nature of sports investment decisions. This thesis addresses that gap through the development and empirical application of a structured multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) framework that evaluates sports PE investments on a 0-100 composite scale, called Sports Private Equity Investment Scoring (SPEIS) model. The model is applied prospectively to three case studies spanning distinct sports markets and regulatory environments: Manchester United-INEOS Sport (English Premier League, 2023), Miami Dolphins-Ares Management (National Football League, 2024), and McLaren Racing-MSP Sports Capital (Formula One, 2020). The model produces differentiated and internally consistent verdicts. Manchester United’s evidence reflects strong brand equity and value-creation lever width offset by execution risk and a full-price entry. The Miami Dolphins presents an expensive EV/EBITDA entry and constrained operational levers under NFL passive-minority ownership rules. McLaren registers financial distress at entry, but with the most compelling override rationale in the sample. This prospective verdict is retrospectively validated by MSP’s confirmed exit in September 2025, placing the investment in the top decile of global PE returns.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
2026_07_Foti_Thesis.pdf
non accessibile
Dimensione
2.31 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
2.31 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
|
2026_07_Foti_ExecutiveSummary.pdf
non accessibile
Dimensione
817.95 kB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
817.95 kB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
I documenti in POLITesi sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/10589/260739