Electrification of agricultural tractors is aimed at reducing emissions, operational costs, and maintenance needs. But, by reducing the dominant engine noise, the drivetrain noise, vibration, and harshness become more audible. Gear whine and gear rattle are important design issues in high-speed electric tractors due to higher reduction ratios, higher motor velocities, and reduced tooth backlash. This thesis explores the necessity of a computationally efficient and predictive model to study the dynamic behavior of electric vehicle tractor gear pairs prior to prototype testing. In Simcenter AMESim, a nonlinear aggregated parameter model of a two-stage spur gear train was built. The model generalizes the gear-pair assumption of modularity from prior work to the electric vehicle tractor domain. The model includes features such as planar rigid body dynamics, torsional shaft stiffness, contact loss and reengagement due to backlash, friction in gear pairs, pre-computed time-varying maps of mesh stiffness, and load-dependent bearing stiffness. These maps were obtained through our previously developed CAD-based parameterization and finite element and static studies. The laboratory transmission tests, comprising two sets of planetary gear trains and a flexible multi-body finite-element model for the worst-case gear train, were compared to numerical simulation, which was carried out using a fixed-step 4th-order Runge-Kutta method. For most of the simulations, we used a time step 1×10−6 s to consistently handle loss of contact, re-engagement, and high-frequency content. For the reference scenario described, the model was executed with a nominal motor speed of 16,011 rpm, an input torque of around 75 Nm, and a backlash clearance of 0.0001795 m. Since both gear meshes stayed on the loaded flank, the response in this case was more in line with a gear-whine regime than a rattle regime. Tooth contact was maintained, the backlash reduced the dynamic transmission error, and only minor oscillatory aberrations were noted. With a variance of 1-2 Nm, the first mesh delivered roughly 70 Nm, while the second mesh communicated roughly 345 Nm with a steady positive signal. Gears 1-2’s time-varying mesh stiffness, which varied between around 726 and 770 MN/m, confirmed that the primary reaction was periodic modulation of force and torque at mesh frequency and its harmonics. However, with values ranging from roughly 726.5 to 730.5 MN/m, gears 3-4 showed a much flatter curve. This behavior was distinguished from the broadband behavior induced by impact. The study shows the effectiveness of a nonlinear lumped-parameter model to emulate the main NVH mechanisms of a high-speed electric vehicle tractor gearbox, with computational feasibility for simulations in the design stage. The present analysis shows that under loaded operating conditions the drivetrain exhibits a whine-dominant character and uniform tooth contact. The draft, on the other hand, indicates that rattling will occur when torque is near zero or changing direction. Thus, the model provides a significant virtual test bench for the development of a quieter electric tractor drivetrain. However, the next steps that can be taken to quantify in more details the rattling onset and to improve the calibration of damping and stiffness require the development of more sophisticated coast/regen cases, zero crossing torque cases, and experimental correlation.
L’elettrificazione dei trattori agricoli mira a ridurre le emissioni, i costi operativi e le esigenze di manutenzione. Tuttavia, riducendo il rumore dominante del motore, diventano più percepibili il rumore, le vibrazioni e la ruvidità di funzionamento della trasmissione. Il fischio degli ingranaggi e il battito degli ingranaggi rappresentano importanti problematiche progettuali nei trattori elettrici ad alta velocità, a causa di rapporti di riduzione più elevati, maggiori velocità del motore e un gioco tra i denti ridotto. Questa tesi esplora la necessità di un modello predittivo e computazionalmente efficiente per studiare il comportamento dinamico delle coppie di ingranaggi dei trattori elettrici prima delle prove su prototipo. In Simcenter AMESim ‘e stato sviluppato un modello non lineare a parametri concentrati di un treno di ingranaggi cilindrici a denti dritti a due stadi. Il modello estende al dominio dei trattori elettrici l’ipotesi di modularit‘a della coppia di ingranaggi proposta in lavori precedenti. Esso include la dinamica planare dei corpi rigidi, la rigidezza torsionale degli alberi, la perdita di contatto e il successivo riingaggio dovuti al gioco, l’attrito nelle coppie di ingranaggi, mappe pre-calcolate e variabili nel tempo della rigidezza di ingranamento, nonch’e la rigidezza dei cuscinetti dipendente dal carico. Tali mappe sono state ottenute mediante la parametrizzazione basata su CAD sviluppata in precedenza, insieme a studi agli elementi finiti e ad analisi statiche. Le prove di laboratorio sulla trasmissione sono state confrontate con le simulazioni numeriche, eseguite mediante un metodo di Runge–Kutta del quarto ordine a passo fisso. Per la maggior parte delle simulazioni ‘e stato adottato un passo temporale pari a 1 × 10−6, s, al fine di descrivere in modo coerente la perdita di contatto, il ri-ingaggio e il contenuto ad alta frequenza. Per lo scenario di riferimento descritto, il modello è stato eseguito con una velocità nominale del motore pari a 16.011 giri/min, una coppia in ingresso di circa 75 Nm e un gioco pari a 0,0001795 m. Poiché entrambe le maglie di ingranamento sono rimaste sul fianco caricato, la risposta in questo caso è risultata più coerente con un regime di fischio degli ingranaggi che con un regime di battito. Il contatto tra i denti è stato mantenuto, il gioco ha ridotto l’errore dinamico di trasmissione e sono state osservate solo lievi anomalie oscillatory. Con una variazione di 1–2 Nm, la prima maglia ha trasmesso circa 70 Nm, mentre la seconda maglia ha comunicato circa 345 Nm con un segnale positivo stabile. La rigidezza di ingranamento variabile nel tempo degli ingranaggi 1–2, compresa tra circa 726 e 770 MN/m, ha confermato che la risposta principale era una modulazione periodica della forza e della coppia alla frequenza di ingranamento e alle sue armoniche. Tuttavia, con valori compresi approssimativamente tra 726,5 e 730,5 MN/m, gli ingranaggi 3–4 hanno mostrato una curva molto più piatta. Questo comportamento è stato distinto dal comportamento a banda larga indotto dagli impatti. Lo studio dimostra l’efficacia di un modello non lineare a parametri concentrati nel riprodurre i principali meccanismi NVH di una trasmissione per trattore elettrico ad alta velocità, mantenendo una fattibilità computazionale adeguata per le simulazioni nella fase di progettazione. L’analisi attuale mostra che, in condizioni operative sotto carico, la trasmissione presenta un comportamento dominato dal fischio e un contatto uniforme tra i denti. La bozza, d’altra parte, indica che il battito si verifica quando la coppia è prossima allo zero o cambia direzione. Pertanto, il modello fornisce un importante banco di prova virtuale per lo sviluppo di una trasmissione per trattore elettrico più silenziosa. Tuttavia, i prossimi passi necessari per quantificare in maggior dettaglio l’innesco del battito e migliorare la calibrazione dello smorzamento e della rigidezza richiedono lo sviluppo di casi più sofisticati di coast/regen, casi con attraversamento dello zero della coppia e correlazione sperimentale.
Dynamic modeling and NVH analysis of a high-speed electric tractor geatrain using a non-linear lumped parameter approach
Anand, Abhijeet
2025/2026
Abstract
Electrification of agricultural tractors is aimed at reducing emissions, operational costs, and maintenance needs. But, by reducing the dominant engine noise, the drivetrain noise, vibration, and harshness become more audible. Gear whine and gear rattle are important design issues in high-speed electric tractors due to higher reduction ratios, higher motor velocities, and reduced tooth backlash. This thesis explores the necessity of a computationally efficient and predictive model to study the dynamic behavior of electric vehicle tractor gear pairs prior to prototype testing. In Simcenter AMESim, a nonlinear aggregated parameter model of a two-stage spur gear train was built. The model generalizes the gear-pair assumption of modularity from prior work to the electric vehicle tractor domain. The model includes features such as planar rigid body dynamics, torsional shaft stiffness, contact loss and reengagement due to backlash, friction in gear pairs, pre-computed time-varying maps of mesh stiffness, and load-dependent bearing stiffness. These maps were obtained through our previously developed CAD-based parameterization and finite element and static studies. The laboratory transmission tests, comprising two sets of planetary gear trains and a flexible multi-body finite-element model for the worst-case gear train, were compared to numerical simulation, which was carried out using a fixed-step 4th-order Runge-Kutta method. For most of the simulations, we used a time step 1×10−6 s to consistently handle loss of contact, re-engagement, and high-frequency content. For the reference scenario described, the model was executed with a nominal motor speed of 16,011 rpm, an input torque of around 75 Nm, and a backlash clearance of 0.0001795 m. Since both gear meshes stayed on the loaded flank, the response in this case was more in line with a gear-whine regime than a rattle regime. Tooth contact was maintained, the backlash reduced the dynamic transmission error, and only minor oscillatory aberrations were noted. With a variance of 1-2 Nm, the first mesh delivered roughly 70 Nm, while the second mesh communicated roughly 345 Nm with a steady positive signal. Gears 1-2’s time-varying mesh stiffness, which varied between around 726 and 770 MN/m, confirmed that the primary reaction was periodic modulation of force and torque at mesh frequency and its harmonics. However, with values ranging from roughly 726.5 to 730.5 MN/m, gears 3-4 showed a much flatter curve. This behavior was distinguished from the broadband behavior induced by impact. The study shows the effectiveness of a nonlinear lumped-parameter model to emulate the main NVH mechanisms of a high-speed electric vehicle tractor gearbox, with computational feasibility for simulations in the design stage. The present analysis shows that under loaded operating conditions the drivetrain exhibits a whine-dominant character and uniform tooth contact. The draft, on the other hand, indicates that rattling will occur when torque is near zero or changing direction. Thus, the model provides a significant virtual test bench for the development of a quieter electric tractor drivetrain. However, the next steps that can be taken to quantify in more details the rattling onset and to improve the calibration of damping and stiffness require the development of more sophisticated coast/regen cases, zero crossing torque cases, and experimental correlation.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
2026_07_Anand_Thesis_01.pdf
non accessibile
Dimensione
9.68 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
9.68 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
|
2026_07_Anand_Executive Summary_02.pdf
non accessibile
Dimensione
2.59 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
2.59 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
I documenti in POLITesi sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/10589/260922