In digital services, engagement is central to user experience design. Many systems rely on continuous stimulation and intermittent rewards, prioritising time spent and repeated use while contributing to cognitive overload and a diminished sense of meaning. This research examines engagement grounded in intrinsic motivation, awareness, agency, and well-being. The research asks how gamification can support positive engagement in digital ecosystems without relying on manipulative mechanisms or predominantly extrinsic incentives. It identifies principles for distinguishing well-being-oriented gamification from extractive models and defines a replicable process for real-world application. The theoretical framework combines Positive Psychology, Self-Determination Theory, game design, and the Octalysis Framework to analyse and design motivational drivers that support experiential quality and motivational balance. Following on from the Laboratorio di Sintesi Finale course “NEXT Mobility”, the research develops Through The Noise, a participatory communication campaign focused on urban mobility in Milan’s stations. Narrative, progression, and characters guide users in reporting behavioural, emotional, and urban forms of interference affecting their journeys. These contributions feed into a shared dataset, making recurring issues visible and supporting design processes. The project was evaluated through an online user test involving participant profiling, an A/B comparison between a traditional survey and an equivalent gamified version, a Bridge Analysis, and prototype testing during onboarding and later use. The evaluation integrates CEAA (Clarity, Engagement, Agency, and Awareness), perceived usability, and Octalysis-based analysis of motivational drivers. Within the sample, the gamified version was preferred, more engaging, and better able to support agency, awareness, and intention to contribute, while maintaining clarity and usability. White Hat drivers related to meaning and progress were predominant. The findings provide preliminary evidence that gamification can function as a motivational and participatory system capable of fostering more positive engagement.
Nei servizi digitali l’engagement è centrale nella progettazione dell’esperienza utente. Molti sistemi ricorrono a stimolazione continua e ricompense intermittenti, privilegiando permanenza e frequenza d’uso e generando sovraccarico cognitivo e perdita di significato. La ricerca indaga un engagement fondato su motivazione intrinseca, consapevolezza, agency e benessere. La domanda di ricerca è: come può la gamification contribuire alla progettazione di forme di engagement positivo negli ecosistemi digitali senza ricorrere a dinamiche manipolative o estrinseche? L’indagine identifica principi per distinguere la gamification orientata al benessere dai modelli estrattivi e definisce un processo replicabile e applicabile in contesti reali. Il quadro teorico integra Positive Psychology, Self-Determination Theory, game design e Octalysis Framework, impiegato per analizzare e progettare le leve motivazionali con criteri di qualità dell’esperienza e bilanciamento motivazionale. In continuità con il Laboratorio di Sintesi Finale “NEXT Mobility”, la ricerca sviluppa Through The Noise, una campagna di comunicazione partecipativa sulla mobilità urbana nelle stazioni milanesi. Narrazione, progressione e personaggi guidano la segnalazione delle interferenze comportamentali, emotive e urbane che incidono sul viaggio. I contributi alimentano un dataset condiviso, rendendo visibili criticità ricorrenti e supportando processi progettuali. Il progetto è verificato con uno user test online: profilazione, confronto A/B tra una survey tradizionale e una versione gamificata equivalente, Bridge Analysis e test del prototipo in fase d’uso avanzata. La valutazione integra CEAA (Clarity, Engagement, Agency e Awareness), l’usabilità percepita e le leve motivazionali con Octalysis. Nel campione analizzato, la versione gamificata risulta preferita, più coinvolgente e capace di sostenere agency, consapevolezza e intenzione di contribuire, preservando chiarezza e usabilità. Prevalgono leve White Hat legate a significato e progresso. Gli esiti offrono evidenze preliminari a sostegno della gamification come sistema motivazionale e partecipativo, capace di alimentare forme di engagement più positive.
Through the noise : un sistema di gamification per la partecipazione e la raccolta dati sulle esperienze di mobilità urbana : modelli progettuali per sostenere la motivazione e favorire un engagement positivo negli ecosistemi digitali
Argenta, Nicolo
2025/2026
Abstract
In digital services, engagement is central to user experience design. Many systems rely on continuous stimulation and intermittent rewards, prioritising time spent and repeated use while contributing to cognitive overload and a diminished sense of meaning. This research examines engagement grounded in intrinsic motivation, awareness, agency, and well-being. The research asks how gamification can support positive engagement in digital ecosystems without relying on manipulative mechanisms or predominantly extrinsic incentives. It identifies principles for distinguishing well-being-oriented gamification from extractive models and defines a replicable process for real-world application. The theoretical framework combines Positive Psychology, Self-Determination Theory, game design, and the Octalysis Framework to analyse and design motivational drivers that support experiential quality and motivational balance. Following on from the Laboratorio di Sintesi Finale course “NEXT Mobility”, the research develops Through The Noise, a participatory communication campaign focused on urban mobility in Milan’s stations. Narrative, progression, and characters guide users in reporting behavioural, emotional, and urban forms of interference affecting their journeys. These contributions feed into a shared dataset, making recurring issues visible and supporting design processes. The project was evaluated through an online user test involving participant profiling, an A/B comparison between a traditional survey and an equivalent gamified version, a Bridge Analysis, and prototype testing during onboarding and later use. The evaluation integrates CEAA (Clarity, Engagement, Agency, and Awareness), perceived usability, and Octalysis-based analysis of motivational drivers. Within the sample, the gamified version was preferred, more engaging, and better able to support agency, awareness, and intention to contribute, while maintaining clarity and usability. White Hat drivers related to meaning and progress were predominant. The findings provide preliminary evidence that gamification can function as a motivational and participatory system capable of fostering more positive engagement.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
2026_07_Argenta.pdf
accessibile in internet solo dagli utenti autorizzati
Descrizione: Testo Tesi
Dimensione
72.11 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
72.11 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
I documenti in POLITesi sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/10589/260940