Metropolitan regions have become increasingly important in addressing urban challenges that extend beyond municipal boundaries, including housing, mobility, environmental sustainability, and territorial development. To improve coordination across fragmented administrative systems, several European countries have introduced metropolitan governance reforms. However, these reforms have produced different institutional arrangements and continue to raise questions about governance capacity, political coordination, and long-term effectiveness. This thesis presents a comparative analysis of the Àrea Metropolitana de Barcelona (AMB) and the Métropole du Grand Paris (MGP). The research is structured around four analytical dimensions: institutional design and conditions of emergence; governance structures and political tensions; competences and operational tools; and legitimacy, visibility, and spatial justice. The analysis also considers recent debates and developments to examine how both metropolitan models have evolved since their establishment. The research is based on a qualitative comparative case study methodology using academic literature, institutional reports, planning documents, and policy analyses. The findings show that metropolitan governance cannot be explained by institutional design alone. The capacity of metropolitan institutions depends on the relationship between formal competences, implementation tools, political support, and territorial context. While the AMB has developed stronger operational capacities through institutional consolidation, the MGP continues to rely on coordination among multiple governmental actors within a more complex multi-level governance system. The comparison highlights that metropolitan governance models are strongly shaped by local political and institutional conditions and cannot be directly transferred from one metropolitan context to another.
Le regioni metropolitane hanno assunto un ruolo sempre più importante nell’affrontare sfide urbane che superano i confini amministrativi comunali, tra cui l’edilizia residenziale, la mobilità, la sostenibilità ambientale e lo sviluppo territoriale. Per migliorare il coordinamento all’interno di sistemi amministrativi frammentati, diversi Paesi europei hanno introdotto riforme della governance metropolitana. Tuttavia, tali riforme hanno prodotto assetti istituzionali differenti e continuano a sollevare interrogativi sulla capacità di governance, sul coordinamento politico e sulla loro efficacia nel lungo periodo. Questa tesi presenta un’analisi comparativa dell’Àrea Metropolitana de Barcelona (AMB) e della Métropole du Grand Paris (MGP). La ricerca è strutturata attorno a quattro dimensioni analitiche: il disegno istituzionale e le condizioni di origine; le strutture di governance e le tensioni politiche; le competenze e gli strumenti operativi; la legittimità, la visibilità e la giustizia spaziale. L’analisi prende inoltre in considerazione i dibattiti e gli sviluppi più recenti per esaminare l’evoluzione dei due modelli metropolitani dopo la loro istituzione. La ricerca si basa su una metodologia qualitativa di studio comparato di casi, utilizzando letteratura scientifica, documenti istituzionali e strumenti di pianificazione. I risultati mostrano che la governance metropolitana non può essere spiegata esclusivamente dal disegno istituzionale. La capacità delle istituzioni metropolitane dipende dal rapporto tra competenze formali, strumenti di attuazione, sostegno politico e contesto territoriale. Mentre l’AMB ha sviluppato una maggiore capacità operativa attraverso il consolidamento istituzionale, la MGP continua a basarsi sul coordinamento tra molteplici attori governativi all’interno di un sistema di governance multilivello più complesso. Il confronto evidenzia come i modelli di governance metropolitana siano fortemente influenzati dalle condizioni politiche e istituzionali locali e non possano essere trasferiti direttamente da un contesto metropolitano a un altro.
Metropolitan governance after institutional reforms : the cases of Barcelona and Grand Paris
VALIZADEH YADKOORI, JAVAD
2025/2026
Abstract
Metropolitan regions have become increasingly important in addressing urban challenges that extend beyond municipal boundaries, including housing, mobility, environmental sustainability, and territorial development. To improve coordination across fragmented administrative systems, several European countries have introduced metropolitan governance reforms. However, these reforms have produced different institutional arrangements and continue to raise questions about governance capacity, political coordination, and long-term effectiveness. This thesis presents a comparative analysis of the Àrea Metropolitana de Barcelona (AMB) and the Métropole du Grand Paris (MGP). The research is structured around four analytical dimensions: institutional design and conditions of emergence; governance structures and political tensions; competences and operational tools; and legitimacy, visibility, and spatial justice. The analysis also considers recent debates and developments to examine how both metropolitan models have evolved since their establishment. The research is based on a qualitative comparative case study methodology using academic literature, institutional reports, planning documents, and policy analyses. The findings show that metropolitan governance cannot be explained by institutional design alone. The capacity of metropolitan institutions depends on the relationship between formal competences, implementation tools, political support, and territorial context. While the AMB has developed stronger operational capacities through institutional consolidation, the MGP continues to rely on coordination among multiple governmental actors within a more complex multi-level governance system. The comparison highlights that metropolitan governance models are strongly shaped by local political and institutional conditions and cannot be directly transferred from one metropolitan context to another.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
2026_07_Valizadeh Yadkoori.pdf
accessibile in internet per tutti
Descrizione: Final Thesis
Dimensione
19.53 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
19.53 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
I documenti in POLITesi sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/10589/261389