Design and engineering collaboration is increasingly recognised as a structural requirement in product development, yet the tools available to support it remain unevenly distributed across the design process. This study addresses a gap in the existing literature: the absence of a systematic map of collaborative visual and tangible tools referenced to the specific phases of a structured Design & Engineering (D&E) process. The research develops an analytical method — the Tool Analysis Scheme — for describing and phase-situating collaborative visual and tangible tools. The scheme organises each tool across three analytical dimensions: Identity, Artefact, and Collaborative Function. Three mapping criteria drawn from the theoretical framework on collaboration — primary collaborative process, type of collaboration enabled, and degree of structure provided — are combined to derive a phase assignment for each tool within the DElta model, a process framework developed at the MSc in Design & Engineering at Politecnico di Milano. The method is applied to sixteen tools selected from the design, service design, and participatory design literature. Individual analyses are followed by a cross-case comparison examining types of collaboration supported, the role of artefacts, and the relationship between output lifespan and degree of structure. The resulting mapping reveals a landscape that is heavily concentrated in the early phases of the D&E process — Analysis & Synthesis and Concept Generation — and entirely absent in Design Detailing. No tool in the set was designed to support the collaborative demands of the final phase, where structured convergence and formal documentation are most needed. The study contributes two things: a replicable analytical method that can be applied to tools beyond those examined here, and a systematic description of where the current landscape of collaborative tools is rich and where it is not. The findings have direct implications for D&E education, pointing toward a design challenge that the existing literature has not yet addressed.
La collaborazione tra design e ingegneria è sempre più riconosciuta come un requisito strutturale nello sviluppo di prodotto, eppure gli strumenti disponibili per supportarla rimangono distribuiti in modo disomogeneo lungo il processo progettuale. Questo studio affronta una lacuna nella letteratura esistente: l'assenza di una mappatura sistematica degli strumenti collaborativi visivi e tangibili riferita alle fasi specifiche di un processo Design & Engineering (D&E) strutturato. La ricerca sviluppa un metodo analitico — il Tool Analysis Scheme — per descrivere e collocare gli strumenti collaborativi visivi e tangibili all'interno delle fasi di processo. Lo schema organizza ogni strumento secondo tre dimensioni analitiche: Identità, Artefatto e Funzione Collaborativa. Tre criteri di mappatura derivati dal framework teorico sulla collaborazione — il processo collaborativo primario supportato, il tipo di collaborazione abilitata e il grado di struttura fornito — vengono combinati per derivare l'assegnazione di fase di ogni strumento all'interno del modello DElta, un framework di processo sviluppato presso il corso di laurea magistrale in Design & Engineering del Politecnico di Milano. Il metodo viene applicato a sedici strumenti selezionati dalla letteratura sul design, il service design e il design partecipativo. Le analisi individuali sono seguite da un confronto trasversale che esamina i tipi di collaborazione supportati, il ruolo degli artefatti e la relazione tra durata dell'output e grado di struttura. La mappatura risultante rivela un panorama fortemente concentrato nelle fasi iniziali del processo D&E — Analysis & Synthesis e Concept Generation — e completamente assente nella fase di Design Detailing. Nessuno degli strumenti analizzati è stato progettato per supportare le esigenze collaborative della fase conclusiva, quella in cui la convergenza strutturata e la documentazione formale sono più necessarie. Lo studio contribuisce con due elementi strettamente correlati: un metodo analitico replicabile, applicabile a strumenti non inclusi in questa ricerca, e una descrizione sistematica di dove il panorama attuale degli strumenti collaborativi è ricco e dove invece non lo è. I risultati hanno implicazioni dirette per la didattica D&E e indicano una sfida progettuale che la letteratura esistente non ha ancora affrontato.
Mapping collaborative tools for design engineering education: an analytical framework for visual and tangible artefacts
NOVATI, MARCO
2025/2026
Abstract
Design and engineering collaboration is increasingly recognised as a structural requirement in product development, yet the tools available to support it remain unevenly distributed across the design process. This study addresses a gap in the existing literature: the absence of a systematic map of collaborative visual and tangible tools referenced to the specific phases of a structured Design & Engineering (D&E) process. The research develops an analytical method — the Tool Analysis Scheme — for describing and phase-situating collaborative visual and tangible tools. The scheme organises each tool across three analytical dimensions: Identity, Artefact, and Collaborative Function. Three mapping criteria drawn from the theoretical framework on collaboration — primary collaborative process, type of collaboration enabled, and degree of structure provided — are combined to derive a phase assignment for each tool within the DElta model, a process framework developed at the MSc in Design & Engineering at Politecnico di Milano. The method is applied to sixteen tools selected from the design, service design, and participatory design literature. Individual analyses are followed by a cross-case comparison examining types of collaboration supported, the role of artefacts, and the relationship between output lifespan and degree of structure. The resulting mapping reveals a landscape that is heavily concentrated in the early phases of the D&E process — Analysis & Synthesis and Concept Generation — and entirely absent in Design Detailing. No tool in the set was designed to support the collaborative demands of the final phase, where structured convergence and formal documentation are most needed. The study contributes two things: a replicable analytical method that can be applied to tools beyond those examined here, and a systematic description of where the current landscape of collaborative tools is rich and where it is not. The findings have direct implications for D&E education, pointing toward a design challenge that the existing literature has not yet addressed.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
2025_07_Novati.pdf
accessibile in internet solo dagli utenti autorizzati
Descrizione: testo tesi
Dimensione
54.45 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
54.45 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
I documenti in POLITesi sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/10589/261400