The vertical jump is one of the most widely used tests in biomechanical movement analysis, as it allows objective assessment of the neuromuscular function of the lower limbs. Jump parameters are generally measured using motion capture systems (MCap) and force platforms (FP), which are considered the gold standard in terms of accuracy and reliability. However, their high cost and the need to operate in controlled environments limit their use outside the laboratory. In this context, inertial measurement units (IMUs) represent a promising solution due to their relatively low cost and the possibility of collecting data directly in the field. The aim of this study was to assess the precision and the accuracy of a wearable inertial sensor positioned at the sacral level by comparing its measurements with those obtained from two gold standard systems (FP and MCap). To this end, 18 healthy participants (10 men and 8 women; mean age = 27.39 ± 5.46 years) were recruited and asked to perform five Squat Jumps and five Drop Jumps. Data collected by the Xsens DOT IMU sensor were compared with those obtained by means of gold standard technology, a motion capture system and a force platform, for the estimation of spatiotemporal parameters, such as jump height, flight time, and contact time. The analysis was supported by statistical tests, including the Shapiro-Wilk normality test, the paired t-test or Wilcoxon signed-rank test, Bland-Altman analysis, root mean square error (RMSE), and intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC). The results showed good agreement between the IMU and the reference systems. In the Squat Jump, the IMU showed excellent agreement with the force platform for jump height (bias = 0.58 cm, RMSE = 1.38 cm, ICC = 0.986) and flight time (bias = 4.60 ms, RMSE = 11.3 ms, ICC = 0.986), while comparison with the optoelectronic system showed a slight tendency to underestimate values, whereas maintaining high reliability levels (jump height: bias = -3.12 cm, RMSE = 3.58 cm, ICC = 0.916; flight time: bias = -25.5 ms, RMSE = 29.4 ms, ICC = 0.913). In the Drop Jump, agreement with the force platform was excellent for jump height (bias = 1.14 cm, RMSE = 14.9 cm, ICC = 0.988), flight time (bias = 10.8 ms, RMSE = 14.9 ms, ICC = 0.987), and contact time (bias = -13.2 ms, RMSE = 22.1 ms, ICC = 0.986), while comparison with the optoelectronic system confirmed similarly high agreement, accompanied by a limited underestimation (jump height: bias = -0.77 cm, RMSE = 2.38 cm, ICC = 0.973; flight time: bias = -8.00 ms, RMSE = 26.0 ms, ICC = 0.958; contact time: bias = -3.80 ms, RMSE = 29.7 ms, ICC = 0.974). Overall, the sacrum-mounted IMU seems to be a valid tool for estimating the three parameters examined. Its characteristics make it suitable for real-world settings, with interesting prospects for functional assessment and sports performance monitoring.
Il salto verticale rappresenta uno dei test più utilizzati nell’analisi biomeccanica del movimento, in quanto consente di valutare in modo oggettivo la funzionalità neuromuscolare degli arti inferiori. I parametri del salto vengono generalmente misurati mediante sistemi optoelettronici (MCap) e piattaforme di forza (FP), considerati i gold standard per accuratezza e affidabilità. Tuttavia, l’elevato costo e la necessità di operare in ambienti controllati ne limitano l’impiego al di fuori del laboratorio. In questo contesto, le unità di misura inerziali (IMU) rappresentano una soluzione promettente grazie al costo contenuto e alla possibilità di effettuare acquisizioni direttamente sul campo. Lo scopo dello studio è stato valutare l’affidabilità e l’accuratezza di un sensore inerziale indossabile, posizionato a livello del sacro, confrontandolo con due sistemi di riferimento (FP e MCap). A tal fine, sono stati reclutati 18 soggetti sani (10 uomini e 8 donne; età media = 27.39 ± 5.46 anni), ai quali è stato richiesto di eseguire cinque Squat Jump e cinque Drop Jump. I dati acquisiti dal sensore IMU Xsens DOT sono stati confrontati con quelli ottenuti dai gold standard, ovvero un sistema optoelettronico e una piattaforma di forza, per la stima di parametri spazio-temporali, quali altezza del salto, tempo di volo e tempo di contatto. L’analisi è stata supportata da test statistici, tra cui il test di normalità di Shapiro-Wilk, il t-test per campioni appaiati o il test di Wilcoxon signed-rank test, l’analisi di Bland-Altman, l’errore quadratico medio (RMSE) e il coefficiente di correlazione intraclasse (ICC). I risultati hanno evidenziato una buona concordanza tra IMU e sistemi di riferimento. Nello Squat Jump, l’IMU ha mostrato un accordo eccellente con la piattaforma di forza per l’altezza del salto (bias = 0.58 cm, RMSE = 1.38 cm, ICC = 0.986) e il tempo di volo (bias = 4.60 ms, RMSE = 11.3 ms, ICC = 0.986), mentre il confronto con il sistema optoelettronico ha evidenziato una lieve tendenza alla sottostima, pur mantenendo livelli di affidabilità elevati (altezza del salto: bias = -3.12 cm, RMSE = 3.58 cm, ICC = 0.916; tempo di volo: bias = -25.5 ms, RMSE = 29.4 ms, ICC = 0.913). Nel Drop Jump, l’accordo con la piattaforma di forza è risultato eccellente per altezza del salto (bias = 1.14 cm, RMSE = 14.9 cm, ICC = 0.988), tempo di volo (bias = 10.8 ms, RMSE = 14.9 ms, ICC = 0.987) e tempo di contatto (bias = -13.2 ms, RMSE = 22.1 ms, ICC = 0.986), mentre il confronto con il sistema optoelettronico ha confermato una concordanza comunque elevata, accompagnata da una sottostima contenuta (altezza del salto: bias = -0.77 cm, RMSE = 2.38 cm, ICC = 0.973; tempo di volo: bias = -8.00 ms, RMSE= 26.0 ms, ICC = 0.958, tempo di contatto: bias = -3.80 ms, RMSE = 29.7 ms, ICC= 0.974). Nel complesso, il sensore IMU posizionato a livello del sacro sembrerebbe essere uno strumento valido per la stima dei tre parametri analizzati. Le sue caratteristiche lo rendono adatto a contesti reali, con interessanti prospettive per la valutazione funzionale e il monitoraggio della performance sportiva.
Valutazione della precisione e dell'accuratezza di un sensore inerziale IMU nei test di Squat Jump e Drop Jump in soggetti sani
Ferrero, Diletta
2025/2026
Abstract
The vertical jump is one of the most widely used tests in biomechanical movement analysis, as it allows objective assessment of the neuromuscular function of the lower limbs. Jump parameters are generally measured using motion capture systems (MCap) and force platforms (FP), which are considered the gold standard in terms of accuracy and reliability. However, their high cost and the need to operate in controlled environments limit their use outside the laboratory. In this context, inertial measurement units (IMUs) represent a promising solution due to their relatively low cost and the possibility of collecting data directly in the field. The aim of this study was to assess the precision and the accuracy of a wearable inertial sensor positioned at the sacral level by comparing its measurements with those obtained from two gold standard systems (FP and MCap). To this end, 18 healthy participants (10 men and 8 women; mean age = 27.39 ± 5.46 years) were recruited and asked to perform five Squat Jumps and five Drop Jumps. Data collected by the Xsens DOT IMU sensor were compared with those obtained by means of gold standard technology, a motion capture system and a force platform, for the estimation of spatiotemporal parameters, such as jump height, flight time, and contact time. The analysis was supported by statistical tests, including the Shapiro-Wilk normality test, the paired t-test or Wilcoxon signed-rank test, Bland-Altman analysis, root mean square error (RMSE), and intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC). The results showed good agreement between the IMU and the reference systems. In the Squat Jump, the IMU showed excellent agreement with the force platform for jump height (bias = 0.58 cm, RMSE = 1.38 cm, ICC = 0.986) and flight time (bias = 4.60 ms, RMSE = 11.3 ms, ICC = 0.986), while comparison with the optoelectronic system showed a slight tendency to underestimate values, whereas maintaining high reliability levels (jump height: bias = -3.12 cm, RMSE = 3.58 cm, ICC = 0.916; flight time: bias = -25.5 ms, RMSE = 29.4 ms, ICC = 0.913). In the Drop Jump, agreement with the force platform was excellent for jump height (bias = 1.14 cm, RMSE = 14.9 cm, ICC = 0.988), flight time (bias = 10.8 ms, RMSE = 14.9 ms, ICC = 0.987), and contact time (bias = -13.2 ms, RMSE = 22.1 ms, ICC = 0.986), while comparison with the optoelectronic system confirmed similarly high agreement, accompanied by a limited underestimation (jump height: bias = -0.77 cm, RMSE = 2.38 cm, ICC = 0.973; flight time: bias = -8.00 ms, RMSE = 26.0 ms, ICC = 0.958; contact time: bias = -3.80 ms, RMSE = 29.7 ms, ICC = 0.974). Overall, the sacrum-mounted IMU seems to be a valid tool for estimating the three parameters examined. Its characteristics make it suitable for real-world settings, with interesting prospects for functional assessment and sports performance monitoring.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
2026_07_Ferrero_Tesi.pdf
accessibile in internet per tutti
Descrizione: Testo della tesi
Dimensione
2.21 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
2.21 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
|
2026_07_Ferrero_ExecutiveSummary.pdf
accessibile in internet per tutti
Descrizione: Executive Summary
Dimensione
885.08 kB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
885.08 kB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
I documenti in POLITesi sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/10589/261517