This thesis aims to examine the role of Corporate Real Estate (CRE) as an operational resource and as a capital allocation decision, focusing on the retail sector. The analysis begins with the structure and functioning of real estate markets and then moves to the corporate perspective, looking at how property supports business strategy, operational performance, customer access, brand positioning and organizational flexibility. Retail real estate is given special attention, because the physical store is not only an income-generating asset, but also a direct interface between the firm and the consumer. The key question raised is whether the strategic significance of real estate to a corporate occupier also constitutes sufficient basis for ownership of the underlying property. To address this issue, the thesis constructs a lease-vs-own framework that disentangles the value of controlling and using space from the financial value of holding the residual property claim. So, ownership is not an automatic result of the operational importance of the asset, but an additional investment decision to be considered against the opportunity cost of corporate capital. The framework is applied to the case study of Inditex/Pontegadea, which offers a very clear comparison between a global retail occupier and a dedicated real estate investor. Inditex is perceived as being a high-return operating company that needs location, continuity, flexibility and control in its store network, while Pontegadea is perceived as being a long-term investor that is focused on recurring income, capital preservation and residual property value. A normalized ten year own versus lease model shows a friction adjusted property return of around 6.1% below the 9.89% corporate benchmark used for Inditex. Sensitivity analysis indicates that stronger assumptions of rental growth, entry yield or exit capitalization would be required in order for ownership to be financially competitive within the model. The thesis concludes that the optimal corporate real estate decision is not to maximize ownership or minimize occupancy cost. Value is created by assigning operational control, residual risk and capital to those best equipped to take advantage of them. In retail, therefore, ownership is only justified if the specific benefits of property ownership outweigh the costs of opportunity, illiquidity and concentration risk.
La presente tesi si propone di esaminare il ruolo del Corporate Real Estate (CRE) sia come risorsa operativa sia come decisione di allocazione del capitale, con particolare attenzione al settore Retail. L’analisi prende avvio dalla struttura e dal funzionamento dei mercati immobiliari, per poi adottare la prospettiva dell’impresa, esaminando il modo in cui gli immobili supportano la strategia aziendale, la performance operativa, l’accesso alla clientela, il posizionamento del brand e la flessibilità organizzativa. Una particolare attenzione è dedicata al Retail Real Estate, poiché il punto vendita fisico non rappresenta soltandot un asset in grado di generare reddito, ma costituisce anche un’interfaccia diretta tra l’impresa e il consumatore. La questione centrale affrontata riguarda la possibilità che la rilevanza strategica dell’immobile per un corporate occupier costituisca, di per sé, una motivazione sufficiente per detenere la proprietà dell’asset sottostante. A tal fine, la tesi sviluppa una framework lease-versus-own che distingue il valore derivante dal controllo e dall’utilizzo dello spazio dal valore finanziario associato alla detenzione del diritto residuale sull’immobile. La proprietà, pertanto, non rappresenta una conseguenza automatica dell’importanza operativa dell’asset, bensì un’ulteriore decisione di investimento che deve essere valutata alla luce del costo opportunità del capitale aziendale. Il framework viene applicato al caso studio Inditex/Pontegadea, che offre un confronto particolarmente chiaro tra un operatore retail globale e un investitore immobiliare specializzato. Inditex viene considerata come un’impresa operativa ad elevato rendimento, che necessita di location, continuità, flessibilità e controllo all’interno della propria rete di punti vendita, mentre Pontegadea viene analizzata come un investitore di lungo periodo focalizzato sulla generazione di redditi ricorrenti, sulla conservazione del capitale e sul valore residuale degli immobili. Un modello own-versus-lease normalizzato su un orizzonte di dieci anni evidenzia un rendimento immobiliare, corretto per le frizioni, pari a circa il 6,1% inferiore al benchmark corporate del 9,89% utilizzato per Inditex. L’analisi di sensitività mostra inoltre che sarebbero necessarie ipotesi più favorevoli in termini di crescita dei canoni di locazione, yield di ingresso o tasso di capitalizzazione in uscita affinché la proprietà immobiliare risulti finanziariamente competitiva all’interno del modello. La tesi conclude che la decisione ottimale non consiste né nel massimizzare la proprietà immobiliare né nel massimizzare il costo di occupazione degli spazi. La creazione di valore dipende piuttosto dall’allocazione del controllo operativo, del rischio residuale e dei capitali ai soggetti maggiormente in grado di valorizzarli. Nel settore Retail, pertanto, la proprietà immobiliare risulta giustificata soltanto quando i benefici specifici derivanti dal possesso dell’immobile superano i relativi costi opportunità, i vincoli di illiquidità e il rischio di concentrazione.
Corporate real estate and the conditions for value creation in the retail sector : an own-versus-lease analysis and the Inditex/Pontegadea case study
Arigò, Matilde
2025/2026
Abstract
This thesis aims to examine the role of Corporate Real Estate (CRE) as an operational resource and as a capital allocation decision, focusing on the retail sector. The analysis begins with the structure and functioning of real estate markets and then moves to the corporate perspective, looking at how property supports business strategy, operational performance, customer access, brand positioning and organizational flexibility. Retail real estate is given special attention, because the physical store is not only an income-generating asset, but also a direct interface between the firm and the consumer. The key question raised is whether the strategic significance of real estate to a corporate occupier also constitutes sufficient basis for ownership of the underlying property. To address this issue, the thesis constructs a lease-vs-own framework that disentangles the value of controlling and using space from the financial value of holding the residual property claim. So, ownership is not an automatic result of the operational importance of the asset, but an additional investment decision to be considered against the opportunity cost of corporate capital. The framework is applied to the case study of Inditex/Pontegadea, which offers a very clear comparison between a global retail occupier and a dedicated real estate investor. Inditex is perceived as being a high-return operating company that needs location, continuity, flexibility and control in its store network, while Pontegadea is perceived as being a long-term investor that is focused on recurring income, capital preservation and residual property value. A normalized ten year own versus lease model shows a friction adjusted property return of around 6.1% below the 9.89% corporate benchmark used for Inditex. Sensitivity analysis indicates that stronger assumptions of rental growth, entry yield or exit capitalization would be required in order for ownership to be financially competitive within the model. The thesis concludes that the optimal corporate real estate decision is not to maximize ownership or minimize occupancy cost. Value is created by assigning operational control, residual risk and capital to those best equipped to take advantage of them. In retail, therefore, ownership is only justified if the specific benefits of property ownership outweigh the costs of opportunity, illiquidity and concentration risk.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Arigò_MBE_2026.pdf
accessibile in internet solo dagli utenti autorizzati
Dimensione
14.79 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
14.79 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
I documenti in POLITesi sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/10589/265318