Mergers and acquisitions are commonly justified by expected synergies, yet the value anticipated before a transaction does not automatically translate into value realized after closing. This thesis addresses this gap by examining how the interaction between an acquirer and a target can be assessed before the integration process is fully defined. Building on the Business Model Canvas and on M&A literature concerning synergies, integration, governance, culture and financial feasibility, the research develops the M&A Combination Canvas. The framework analyses the proposed combination through five interconnected areas: synergy identification, operational synergy areas, cultural and organizational integration, innovation and growth opportunities, and financial synergy evaluation. It is complemented by a Synergy Assessment and Sequencing layer, which relates synergy characteristics to their expected realization horizon and degree of managerial controllability. The framework was applied predictively to three transactions: U-Power–CERVA, MPS–Mediobanca and De Agostini–Legami. The applications were complemented by practitioner interviews aimed at assessing and refining the logic of the tool. Across the cases, the analysis highlighted the importance of moving beyond the identification of potential complementarities and examining the conditions required to use them effectively after the transaction. It also reinforced the need to adapt integration choices to the specific value creation logic of each deal and to distinguish between synergies with different implementation horizons and dependencies. The proposed framework is not intended to replace valuation, due diligence or post-merger integration planning. Its contribution is to provide a structured and revisable tool for making acquisition assumptions explicit, identifying the conditions required for value realization and supporting more disciplined pre-acquisition reasoning.
Le operazioni di fusione e acquisizione sono generalmente giustificate attraverso le sinergie attese, ma il valore previsto prima di una transazione non si traduce automaticamente in valore effettivamente realizzato dopo il closing. Questa tesi affronta tale distanza analizzando come l’interazione tra acquirente e target possa essere valutata prima che il processo di integrazione sia completamente definito. Partendo dal Business Model Canvas e dalla letteratura M&A relativa a sinergie, integrazione, governance, cultura e sostenibilità finanziaria, la ricerca sviluppa il M&A Combination Canvas. Il framework analizza la combinazione proposta attraverso cinque aree interconnesse: identificazione delle sinergie, sinergie operative, integrazione culturale e organizzativa, opportunità di innovazione e crescita e valutazione delle sinergie finanziarie. A queste si aggiunge il Synergy Assessment and Sequencing, che mette in relazione le caratteristiche delle sinergie con il loro orizzonte temporale di realizzazione e il grado di controllabilità manageriale. Il framework è stato applicato in modo predittivo a tre operazioni: U-Power–CERVA, MPS–Mediobanca e De Agostini–Legami. Le applicazioni sono state affiancate da interviste con professionisti del settore, utilizzate per valutare e affinare la logica dello strumento. Nei tre casi, l’analisi ha evidenziato l’importanza di andare oltre la semplice identificazione delle complementarità potenziali, considerando anche le condizioni necessarie affinché possano essere effettivamente utilizzate dopo la transazione. Ha inoltre rafforzato la necessità di adattare le scelte di integrazione alla specifica logica di creazione del valore e di distinguere tra sinergie caratterizzate da differenti tempi di realizzazione e livelli di dipendenza da fattori esterni. Il framework proposto non intende sostituire la valutazione, la due diligence o la pianificazione dell’integrazione post-acquisizione. Il suo contributo consiste nel fornire uno strumento strutturato e aggiornabile per rendere esplicite le ipotesi alla base dell’acquisizione, identificare le condizioni necessarie alla realizzazione del valore e supportare un’analisi pre-acquisizione più disciplinata.
Beyond the deal: structuring value creation in MandA through Business Model Combination
BOVI, ALESSANDRO;Bottini, Francesca
2025/2026
Abstract
Mergers and acquisitions are commonly justified by expected synergies, yet the value anticipated before a transaction does not automatically translate into value realized after closing. This thesis addresses this gap by examining how the interaction between an acquirer and a target can be assessed before the integration process is fully defined. Building on the Business Model Canvas and on M&A literature concerning synergies, integration, governance, culture and financial feasibility, the research develops the M&A Combination Canvas. The framework analyses the proposed combination through five interconnected areas: synergy identification, operational synergy areas, cultural and organizational integration, innovation and growth opportunities, and financial synergy evaluation. It is complemented by a Synergy Assessment and Sequencing layer, which relates synergy characteristics to their expected realization horizon and degree of managerial controllability. The framework was applied predictively to three transactions: U-Power–CERVA, MPS–Mediobanca and De Agostini–Legami. The applications were complemented by practitioner interviews aimed at assessing and refining the logic of the tool. Across the cases, the analysis highlighted the importance of moving beyond the identification of potential complementarities and examining the conditions required to use them effectively after the transaction. It also reinforced the need to adapt integration choices to the specific value creation logic of each deal and to distinguish between synergies with different implementation horizons and dependencies. The proposed framework is not intended to replace valuation, due diligence or post-merger integration planning. Its contribution is to provide a structured and revisable tool for making acquisition assumptions explicit, identifying the conditions required for value realization and supporting more disciplined pre-acquisition reasoning.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
2026_10_Bottini_Bovi.pdf
accessibile in internet solo dagli utenti autorizzati
Descrizione: testo tesi
Dimensione
3.39 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
3.39 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
|
2026_10_Bottini_Bovi_Executive Summary.pdf
accessibile in internet solo dagli utenti autorizzati
Descrizione: executive summary
Dimensione
491.8 kB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
491.8 kB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
I documenti in POLITesi sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/10589/266283