Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS) is a multisystem genetic disorder characterized by obesity, hypotonia, reduced muscle strength, and alterations in body composition, which may affect locomotor function and the pendulum-like exchange of energy. This study aimed to assess the energetic efficiency of the pendular mechanism in individuals with PWS through an analysis of anthropometric, spatio-temporal, kinematic and in particular mechanical-energy parameters. Comparisons were made with individuals with non-syndromic obesity and healthy individuals to characterize the PWS gait pattern and identify potential compensatory strategies. A total of 104 adults were included in the study and divided into three groups: 34 individuals with PWS (PWS), 36 individuals with non-syndromic obesity (OG), and 34 healthy weight individuals (HG). Three-dimensional gait analysis was performed at each participant’s self-selected walking speed using an optoelectronic motion capture system (Vicon; sampling frequency: 100 Hz) equipped with 23 retroreflective markers positioned according to the Plug-In Gait model. The center of mass (COM) was approximated as the midpoint between the markers placed on the posterior superior iliac spines (PSIS). Data were processed using dedicated software (Vicon Nexus 1.8, Vicon Polygon 2.4, Smart Analyzer 1.10 and MATLAB R2021a). Group differences were assessed using statistical software (JASP 18.3) through ANOVA followed by Tukey’s post hoc test. ANCOVA was additionally performed for Energy Recovery Index (ERI) and Congruity (C), with walking speed included as a covariate. Finally, correlations were computed to investigate associations between energetic indices and the main gait parameters. Anthropometric parameters showed that the PWS group had lower height than other groups, greater body mass than the HG group but lower body mass than the OG group, and a similar BMI to the OG group. Spatio-temporal analysis revealed lower stride length, walking speed and cadence, and higher stride time, foot-off and double support values in the PWS and OG groups compared with the HG group. In particular, individuals with PWS exhibited lower stride length and walking speed than individuals in the OG group. The PWS group showed a reduced range of motion (ROM) at the knee joint compared with other groups. The work associated with kinetic energy (W_k) was lower in the PWS and OG groups than in the HG group, whereas total mechanical work (W_tot) did not differ significantly among the groups. The efficiency analysis of the pendular mechanism revealed lower ERI and higher C values in the PWS group than in the other groups. Similarly, the OG group exhibited lower ERI and higher C values than the HG group. ANCOVA confirmed that between-group differences in ERI and C remained statistically significant after accounting for walking speed. Pearson’s correlation analyses showed a positive association between the work associated with potential energy (W_p) and hip ROM in all groups, whereas the association between W_k and hip ROM was more pronounced in the OG and HG groups. Overall, these findings suggest that alterations in locomotor strategy in PWS cannot be attributed exclusively to obesity, but may also reflect syndrome-specific characteristics. Assessing pendular mechanism efficiency may therefore provide a useful complement to gait evaluation and contribute to the characterization and monitoring of rehabilitation interventions in individuals with PWS.
La sindrome di Prader-Willi (PWS) è una patologia genetica multisistemica caratterizzata da obesità, ipotonia, ridotta forza muscolare e alterazioni della composizione corporea, che possono influenzare il pattern di deambulazione e la sua efficienza. Tale studio si propone di valutare l’efficienza energetica del meccanismo pendolare dei soggetti affetti da PWS mediante l’analisi di parametri antropometrici, spazio-temporali, cinematici e in particolare energetico-meccanici. I parametri considerati vengono confrontati con quelli di soggetti con obesità e soggetti sani, al fine di caratterizzare il pattern di cammino ed evidenziare eventuali strategie compensatorie associate alla PWS. Sono stati analizzati 104 soggetti adulti, suddivisi in tre gruppi: 34 soggetti affetti dalla sindrome (PWS), 36 soggetti con obesità non sindromica (OG) e 34 soggetti sani normopeso (HG). L’analisi tridimensionale del cammino è stata effettuata a una velocità spontaneamente selezionata dai partecipanti, mediante un sistema optoelettronico (Vicon, frequenza d’acquisizione 100 Hz) dotato di 23 marker retroriflettenti, posizionati secondo il modello Plug-In Gait. Il centro di massa (COM) è stato approssimato come il punto medio tra i marker posizionati sulle spine iliache posteriori superiori (PSIS). I dati sono stati elaborati tramite software dedicati (Vicon Nexus 1.8, Vicon Polygon 2.4, Smart Analyzer 1.10 e MATLAB R2021a). Le differenze tra i gruppi sono state valutate con un software statistico (JASP 18.3) mediante ANOVA e test post hoc di Tukey; per l’Energy Recovery Index (ERI) e Congruity (C) è stata inoltre effettuata un’ANCOVA considerando la walking speed come covariata. Infine, sono state analizzate le correlazioni di Pearson tra gli indici energetici e i principali parametri del cammino. Nei parametri antropometrici è emerso che il gruppo PWS ha un’altezza inferiore rispetto agli altri due gruppi, una massa corporea maggiore rispetto al gruppo HG e inferiore rispetto al gruppo OG e un BMI comparabile al gruppo OG. I parametri spazio-temporali nei gruppi PWS e OG hanno evidenziato valori inferiori di stride length, walking speed e cadence e valori superiori di stride time, foot off e double support rispetto al gruppo HG. In particolare, nei soggetti PWS sono stati osservati valori di stride length e walking speed inferiori rispetto ai soggetti OG. Il range of motion (ROM) del ginocchio del gruppo PWS è risultato ridotto rispetto agli altri due gruppi. Considerando i parametri energetico-meccanici, il lavoro associato alla variazione di energia cinetica (W_k) si è dimostrato inferiore nei gruppi PWS e OG rispetto a HG, mentre il lavoro meccanico totale (W_tot) non ha mostrato differenze significative tra i gruppi. Per quanto riguarda l’efficienza del meccanismo pendolare, il valore dell’ERI si è rivelato inferiore e il valore di C maggiore nei soggetti PWS rispetto agli altri due tipi di soggetti. Analogamente, il gruppo OG ha mostrato un ERI inferiore e una C maggiore rispetto al gruppo HG. L’ANCOVA ha rivelato che le differenze tra i gruppi in ERI e C sono rimaste significative anche dopo aver tenuto conto della walking speed. Le correlazioni di Pearson hanno evidenziato una relazione positiva tra il lavoro associato alla variazione di energia potenziale (W_p) e il ROM dell’anca in tutti i gruppi, mentre il rapporto tra W_k e ROM dell’anca è risultato più marcato nei gruppi OG e HG. Nel complesso, i risultati suggeriscono che le alterazioni della strategia locomotoria nei soggetti con PWS non siano riconducibili esclusivamente alla condizione di obesità, ma possano riflettere anche caratteristiche specifiche della sindrome. L’analisi dell’efficienza del meccanismo pendolare rappresenta pertanto un utile complemento per la valutazione del cammino e potrebbe contribuire alla caratterizzazione e al monitoraggio degli interventi riabilitativi nei soggetti con PWS.
Valutazione dell'efficienza energetica del cammino nella Sindrome di Prader-Willi: confronto con soggetti con obesità e normopeso
Nitidi, Giovanna
2025/2026
Abstract
Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS) is a multisystem genetic disorder characterized by obesity, hypotonia, reduced muscle strength, and alterations in body composition, which may affect locomotor function and the pendulum-like exchange of energy. This study aimed to assess the energetic efficiency of the pendular mechanism in individuals with PWS through an analysis of anthropometric, spatio-temporal, kinematic and in particular mechanical-energy parameters. Comparisons were made with individuals with non-syndromic obesity and healthy individuals to characterize the PWS gait pattern and identify potential compensatory strategies. A total of 104 adults were included in the study and divided into three groups: 34 individuals with PWS (PWS), 36 individuals with non-syndromic obesity (OG), and 34 healthy weight individuals (HG). Three-dimensional gait analysis was performed at each participant’s self-selected walking speed using an optoelectronic motion capture system (Vicon; sampling frequency: 100 Hz) equipped with 23 retroreflective markers positioned according to the Plug-In Gait model. The center of mass (COM) was approximated as the midpoint between the markers placed on the posterior superior iliac spines (PSIS). Data were processed using dedicated software (Vicon Nexus 1.8, Vicon Polygon 2.4, Smart Analyzer 1.10 and MATLAB R2021a). Group differences were assessed using statistical software (JASP 18.3) through ANOVA followed by Tukey’s post hoc test. ANCOVA was additionally performed for Energy Recovery Index (ERI) and Congruity (C), with walking speed included as a covariate. Finally, correlations were computed to investigate associations between energetic indices and the main gait parameters. Anthropometric parameters showed that the PWS group had lower height than other groups, greater body mass than the HG group but lower body mass than the OG group, and a similar BMI to the OG group. Spatio-temporal analysis revealed lower stride length, walking speed and cadence, and higher stride time, foot-off and double support values in the PWS and OG groups compared with the HG group. In particular, individuals with PWS exhibited lower stride length and walking speed than individuals in the OG group. The PWS group showed a reduced range of motion (ROM) at the knee joint compared with other groups. The work associated with kinetic energy (W_k) was lower in the PWS and OG groups than in the HG group, whereas total mechanical work (W_tot) did not differ significantly among the groups. The efficiency analysis of the pendular mechanism revealed lower ERI and higher C values in the PWS group than in the other groups. Similarly, the OG group exhibited lower ERI and higher C values than the HG group. ANCOVA confirmed that between-group differences in ERI and C remained statistically significant after accounting for walking speed. Pearson’s correlation analyses showed a positive association between the work associated with potential energy (W_p) and hip ROM in all groups, whereas the association between W_k and hip ROM was more pronounced in the OG and HG groups. Overall, these findings suggest that alterations in locomotor strategy in PWS cannot be attributed exclusively to obesity, but may also reflect syndrome-specific characteristics. Assessing pendular mechanism efficiency may therefore provide a useful complement to gait evaluation and contribute to the characterization and monitoring of rehabilitation interventions in individuals with PWS.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
2026_10_Nitidi_Tesi.pdf
accessibile in internet solo dagli utenti autorizzati
Descrizione: Testo della tesi
Dimensione
2.04 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
2.04 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
|
2026_10_Nitidi_Executive_ Summary.pdf
accessibile in internet solo dagli utenti autorizzati
Descrizione: Executive Summary
Dimensione
856.03 kB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
856.03 kB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
I documenti in POLITesi sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/10589/266815