This research examines the relationship between disaster, reconstruction, and urban planning. Its premise is that a catastrophe does not coincide solely with the natural event that triggers it, but results from the interaction between physical hazards and the pre-existing conditions of social, economic, institutional, and cultural vulnerability and fragility within a given territory. Reconstructing after a disaster does not simply mean repairing buildings or providing new housing. Rather, it is a much broader process: a complex transformation involving the urban structure, administrative organisation, social relations, collective memory, and the ability of communities to identify with the places in which they live. Taking the 23 November 1980 Irpinia earthquake as a case study, this research investigates the institutional governance choices, spatial planning strategies, and long-term territorial and demographic transformations resulting from post-disaster reconstruction. Through an interdisciplinary approach integrating urban planning, the sociology of disasters, and territorial history, the Irpinia case is examined in dialogue with eight significant disaster events, ranging from the 1908 Messina earthquake to the 2023 Türkiye–Syria earthquake. The research assesses the extent to which the choices adopted in managing the reconstruction process achieved their stated objectives, and identifies lessons that may inform future risk-reduction and post-disaster planning policies. The findings reveal a mixed outcome: significant improvements in the quality of the built environment and infrastructure provision are accompanied by structural challenges in demographic, economic, and governance terms, suggesting the need to fundamentally rethink post-disaster intervention models.
La presente ricerca analizza il rapporto tra disastro, ricostruzione e pianificazione territoriale. Il suo presupposto è che la catastrofe non coincide unicamente con l’evento naturale che la innesca, ma deriva dall’interazione tra una pericolosità fisica e le condizioni di vulnerabilità e fragilità sociale, economica, istituzionale e culturale preesistenti in un determinato territorio. Ricostruire dopo un disastro non significa soltanto riparare edifici o realizzare nuove abitazioni. Si tratta di un processo molto più ampio: una trasformazione complessa che coinvolge la struttura urbana, l’organizzazione amministrativa, le relazioni sociali, la memoria collettiva e la stessa capacità delle comunità di riconoscersi nei luoghi in cui vivono. Assumendo come caso di studio il terremoto dell'Irpinia del 23 novembre 1980, si vogliono indagare le scelte di governance istituzionale, le strategie urbanistiche adottate e le trasformazioni territoriali e demografiche di lungo periodo che derivano dalla ricostruzione post-disastro. Attraverso un approccio interdisciplinare che integra urbanistica, sociologia dei disastri e storia del territorio, il caso irpino viene posto in dialogo con otto significativi episodi di disastro, dal terremoto di Messina del 1908 al sisma turco-siriano del 2023. La ricerca valuta in quale misura le scelte adottate nella gestione della ricostruzione abbiano conseguito gli obiettivi dichiarati e quali insegnamenti sia possibile trarne per future politiche di riduzione del rischio e di pianificazione post-disastro. I risultati evidenziano un bilancio contraddittorio: significativi avanzamenti nella qualità del costruito e nel potenziamento infrastrutturale si accompagnano a criticità strutturali sul piano demografico, economico e della governance, che invitano a ripensare in profondità i modelli di intervento post-catastrofe.
Ricostruire dopo il disastro : pianificazione e trasformazioni territoriali nell'Irpinia del 1980
Macchia, Beatrice
2025/2026
Abstract
This research examines the relationship between disaster, reconstruction, and urban planning. Its premise is that a catastrophe does not coincide solely with the natural event that triggers it, but results from the interaction between physical hazards and the pre-existing conditions of social, economic, institutional, and cultural vulnerability and fragility within a given territory. Reconstructing after a disaster does not simply mean repairing buildings or providing new housing. Rather, it is a much broader process: a complex transformation involving the urban structure, administrative organisation, social relations, collective memory, and the ability of communities to identify with the places in which they live. Taking the 23 November 1980 Irpinia earthquake as a case study, this research investigates the institutional governance choices, spatial planning strategies, and long-term territorial and demographic transformations resulting from post-disaster reconstruction. Through an interdisciplinary approach integrating urban planning, the sociology of disasters, and territorial history, the Irpinia case is examined in dialogue with eight significant disaster events, ranging from the 1908 Messina earthquake to the 2023 Türkiye–Syria earthquake. The research assesses the extent to which the choices adopted in managing the reconstruction process achieved their stated objectives, and identifies lessons that may inform future risk-reduction and post-disaster planning policies. The findings reveal a mixed outcome: significant improvements in the quality of the built environment and infrastructure provision are accompanied by structural challenges in demographic, economic, and governance terms, suggesting the need to fundamentally rethink post-disaster intervention models.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
2026_10_Macchia.pdf
non accessibile
Descrizione: Testo della tesi e appendici
Dimensione
98.35 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
98.35 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
I documenti in POLITesi sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/10589/267118